Beyond the fee: what payments modernization really costs DANNY BRADBURY: Beyond the fee, what payments modernization really costs. I'm Danny Bradbury, your moderator. If you've ever tried to build a real number for what a single payment costs, the line on the bank statement is the easy part, $0.40 for an ACH, $0.80 for a check, except the fully loaded cost of getting a check out the door can climb closer to $9.50. That gap is where most modernization business cases get built or fall apart. Today, two leaders from U.S. Bank will walk us through building a defensible total cost of payment analysis, setting it internally and ensuring that your payment modernization doesn't stall. So I'm joined by two people. Brandon Sather works with clients on the strategic case for modernization, and Anthony Grayson is a former practitioner who now consults to enterprise finance teams on procure to pay. Brandon, welcome. BRANDON SATHER: Thank you, Danny. Glad to be here. I'm the head of strategy for U.S. Bank's corporate payment systems, and a lot of what that means for us today is helping clients understand how they can use payments to help modernize their procure to pay lifecycle. DANNY BRADBURY: Pleased to have you here. And, Anthony, it's great to see you as well. ANTHONY GRAYSON: Hello, Danny. It's a pleasure to be with you here today. And by way of background, prior to me joining the Bank, I was the practitioner that you referenced. I was the director of procure to pay for a large academic medical center here in Nashville. And so I bring the real world experience to our conversation today, and in my tenure now with U.S. Bank, I'm focused on helping clients really optimize all of the aspects within that procure to pay and payment process. DANNY BRADBURY: Excellent. Well, it's great to have you here as well. So let's get started. When a CFO asks, what does a payment cost us, the easy answer is the bank statement line. That's almost never the real number, though, is it? Brandon, what do teams miss? BRANDON SATHER: I think the first thing that comes to mind is some research that we recently did with U.S. Bank of about 2,400 finance leaders last December. 29% of the respondents thought ACH was expensive, compared to 42% for virtual cards. Yet, ACH is actually $8.97 per transaction, and virtual cards come in slightly less at $7.25 per transaction. Juxtaposed against wire costs, which are over $16, but only 50% of respondents thought that was expensive. So what are they missing? I think what they're really missing are the indirect fees, the labor, variability, and volatility costs that kind of seep into the process. The big one, for me, is exception handling along with supplier support, fraud remediation. All these things eat hours in time that never really hits a P&L statement. Things like these, these onesie, twosie costs, they're pretty hard to quantify without doing a rigorous activity based costing measure. And then lastly, I think reconciliation, labor and fraud remediation are two of the biggest undercounted buckets. DANNY BRADBURY: Interesting. OK, and Anthony, what do these activities look like on a daily basis? ANTHONY GRAYSON: You know, Danny, I think Brandon is spot on with his assessment of check costs. While it may only be, let's say, $0.80 of direct costs, that fully loaded cost of that check certainly pushes closer to $9. And I think what's missing here is when you think about the lifespan of that paper check, the disposition process, or many of us just call it escheatment, really becomes a worst case scenario. It's a great deal of effort that's spent on low value types of payments. It's really disproportional return on value. So I think the escheatment process is really one of those day to day things that have those hidden costs that we're addressing. The other part of it comes into what I would consider the vendor maintenance, another one of these hidden costs. And unless you've adopted some sort of supplier portal or automated some of these types of processes, vendor maintenance efforts can be very, very manual. It's one of the most important roles within the financial organization, but it's also extremely, extremely risky as well. In fact, when I think of vendor maintenance, I think of those teams as really holding the keys to the kingdom for a particular organization. So both of those are core costs of making payments and the payment process, but neither of those really show up on the bank statement that we're addressing today. DANNY BRADBURY: So we've seen some of these payment costs then that can stay tucked away, hidden from plain view in general operations, and we've also seen how difficult it is to really quantify those, which puts companies in a difficult position. So, Brandon, how can we surface those costs and put a number to them? BRANDON SATHER: I think the primary way you can do that is through activity-based costing, and I think this is a non-negotiable for all modernization efforts. I think you really have to know and understand where your people are spending their time. It isn't just a counting exercise, so counting exceptions is not enough, because the difference between a two-minute exception and a two-day exception are pretty broad. And if you're having a lot of two-day exceptions, you really need to understand how much time is getting brought into those processes. So what I would caution is beware of using averages or industry reports on the median when you're trying to understand the costs of making payments. One thing that really stands out is back to kind of the two-hour versus two-day analogy. A lot of times, the distributions of these exceptions are bimodal, and the real problem is in the tail of where these costs live versus in the average. DANNY BRADBURY: Got it. And so, Anthony, what benchmarks then should a finance leader use to measure themselves by? ANTHONY GRAYSON: In my former role as a practitioner, really, two key metrics that I was focusing my operations on and that really every organization needs to understand. The first is determining what I call the total cost to perform the function of accounts payable, total cost to perform the function of accounts payable per, let's say, million dollars worth of spend. Critical, critical benchmarking within any organization, as they start to look at and think about their cost structure. Secondly, an organization needs to understand what is their cost, what is their total cost per payment, and that's where the functions, such as the vendor maintenance, the escheatment for those types of activities, really come into play and would certainly encourage organizations to go beyond just understanding that cost for check, but understand that cost per payment for all of your payment channels. And the good news, I think, that really comes out of this is there are several organizations, such as AFP, APQC, that have numerous industry reports, along with industry types of journals that publish these total cost to execute a particular function, as well as these cost per payment types of analysis that they can undertake. And I would say, the most common reaction, once the cost structure is fully understood, as Brandon alluded to above, and they understand the all in cost to perform some of these functions to execute payment, the most common reaction is really just that of shock. What does it really cost us to provide and issue some of these types of payments? And it can be staggering to some organizations. DANNY BRADBURY: And so you're saying, Anthony, just to follow up on that, it's really not until they dig into the AFP numbers that the industry journal reports, that they really start to get a sense of what they're losing on a per check basis? ANTHONY GRAYSON: Absolutely. They really need to understand the fully loaded cost and understand, what are my peers doing, let's say, by a peer industry or company size, to get a sense of where do we have opportunities for improvement? DANNY BRADBURY: Got it. OK, so just following up on some of this discussion, Anthony, I wanted to ask you about the task of selling this to the CFO. Obviously, the CFOs have lots of hats, lots of things on their desk. So even though the finance team might be convinced of the business case for this, they still have to sell it to that officer. How do you frame that conversation and make sure that it lands properly? ANTHONY GRAYSON: Yeah, that's a wonderful question. As a former practitioner, the, really, four key pillars that will land and resonate with your senior leadership, these are the pillars that became the foundation of how I managed my programs and my organization. The first is efficiency. Understand and asking, how does any new initiative, how does it help us get better at what we're currently doing today? The second pillar stems from mitigating risk, and as we think about the adoption of new processes, new technologies, asking ourselves, how are we driving out risk across the entire payment spectrum? Thirdly, I like to look at the economic value, things like rebates, the working capital benefits that are many times buried within our payment processes. And then, finally, the fourth pillar to evaluate this on is what I call redeployment. How can we move our staffs out of lower value, manual effort types of processes and move them into more higher value types of function? And again, the good news from these four pillars correlate and map directly to the outcomes that the CFOs are already tracking. That's where their minds are. Secondly, I would encourage organizations to think about your modernization strategy in comparison to broader organizational goals and objectives. For example, positioning what can this initiative do as we think about operational expansion, what does this initiative do as we think about preparations for an acquisition, or are we preparing for some sort of economic downturn? These are the types of thinkings and thought processes that will resonate with senior leaders within your organization. DANNY BRADBURY: I want to go back to one of these four pillars. The economic value really strikes me as important here and something that CFOs would really find appealing. And you mentioned a couple of things, rebates, working capital. Just for people that maybe haven't grasped some of these benefits, these economic benefits, I'm going to actually ask Brandon this one. Brandon, can you outline some of the things they can expect in terms of economic value from a payment modernization process? BRANDON SATHER: Yeah, I think naturally, we align on a lot of the revenue and the numbers when we look at payments modernization, and I think you can see some very clear ones when you see the cost of a payment go down. But I think Tony made a good point on the hours that people are spending on this, and can we shift them over to more value add things? So it's not always going to be a pure expense go down, but you might get some benefit just from value add or deeper things that these payments staff are working on when they're not spending two days to clear an exception. DANNY BRADBURY: That seems to tie into the redeployment case. So could you talk about some of the things that staff may find themselves able to do, perhaps some of those things that have been on to do list, but they haven't been able to handle them, because they've been fighting fires? Maybe Anthony, I'm going to throw that one over to you. ANTHONY GRAYSON: Yeah, no, I think that's a perfectly timed question. When you think about some of the manual tasks of, as I mentioned earlier, things like escheatment, those are ongoing, day-to-day types of things that take away the time from us to think more strategically and really holistically about implementing new processes, implementing new technologies, where you hear folks say, I just don't feel like I have the time to go pursue some of the more value added types of things that either I'd like to do or my leadership has asked me to do, because I feel like I'm so buried in the day-to-day tasks of just running the business. And again, I love to pick on the escheatment process, because it is, again, so manual, labor intensive, and a disproportionate return on value to the organization. DANNY BRADBURY: Brandon, why is this a risk conversation more than a cost one? BRANDON SATHER: Yeah, I think that's a great question. I think when people think a CFO, the F does a lot of work in the CFO title. So they default to things, like numbers and costs. But I think what a CFO does is often risk assessment. One of the first questions that I frequently hear CFOs ask when I'm presenting modernization efforts or presenting projects is, what is a bad day look like? And so they're really fundamentally trying to solve for, what does it look like when things go wrong? And I think kind of pre-modernization, there's a lot of points of failure. Things can go wrong anywhere in the process, and I think what modernization does for the organizations that undertake it is it reduces the handoffs and the manual touch points, where these mistakes can happen or where these points of failure can materialize. And when I think of the CFOs that I've work for, one of the things that they really dislike the most is unpredictability or volatility. And I think with a lot of the modernization capabilities that we can avail ourselves of today, we can automate a lot of it. And so the automation itself brings predictability into the process. Where we might have had volatility before with handoffs and manual touchpoints, automation will make these things much more predictable and much more certain. So I don't think of it as a risk mitigation. It's almost a risk avoidance by taking out a lot of these points of failure. We're avoiding the risk entirely. In this case, it kind of fixes the exposure by payment size. So what we're controlling for here, rather than the points of failure and the manual touch points, we're controlling for incidence rate on fraud or incidence rate on misuse and abuse, where we can create time in the process for our staffs to investigate these types of things versus constantly being forced to do the manual processing of just getting a payment out the door. DANNY BRADBURY: So, Brandon, we know by now that payment modernization can deliver some real commercial benefits, but we also know that the best technology pitches often don't make it out of the hangar. And so where do well-built business cases for payment modernization stall, and why? BRANDON SATHER: I think the largest constraint that we have to solve for is in technical resourcing. AP is not a revenue generating business. It's not frontline sales and driving new customers, so it competes for resources with initiatives that are revenue generating. So practitioners will get the benefits, but the narrative doesn't necessarily travel upward to the CFO. So I think as we were talking about before with the costing, I think the biggest solve here, the biggest fix is in the upfront baselining, really, understanding the current state, where we can improve, what the risk vectors are that an executive would be interested in. And these are not just the obvious risks. A lot of the risks are what I like to call the dog that isn't barking. It's something that is present today. Maybe it should be evaluated, but no one is looking at it yet, because it hasn't occurred. The dog has not barked yet. So the risk exists, but the signal might not be there just yet. DANNY BRADBURY: And what about you, Anthony? What kills a project that you think is a sure thing? ANTHONY GRAYSON: I can share thoughts from the practitioner side. First and foremost, it's really lack of upward management, lack of many folks' ability to prepare, share the insights, the benefits of a particular initiative and manage that communication upward through their organization. So an AP supervisor or an AP manager, it's great that they may be on board with that. But have they taken the time to effectively lay the groundwork, so that the controller, so that the treasurer of the organization is on board? And many times, if they are not, then we see a very, frankly, sudden and abrupt stop to some of these modernization products and projects that we try to undertake. I also see it from the perspective of within many different types of organizations, to Brandon's point, the allocation of IT resources and how much of that time is allocated to, let's say, finance and administrative types of functions can fall by the wayside, because it's not considered core capabilities of the organization, whether it's in education, manufacturing, or in healthcare, finance, accounts payable. There's just simply not core operations or core functions. So I think it's imperative that the practitioners that we research, that we understand, well, what is the process, what is the ITQ that I have to go through? How are projects, processes, new initiatives, how are they evaluated within the organization, I think, is critically important. And then also, what does the depth chart look like, meaning how many initiatives are ahead of me in terms of Q and my ability to get a resource? Otherwise, you may simply face a scenario take a number, and we'll get to you when we can. So I think the driving, the upward management is critical. Finding and identifying an executive sponsor is always really recognized as a best practice, but understand what is that research IT process to get in the List, Get in the line for your project to be considered. I also think about when we think about financial functions, many of them face the same types of dilemmas. They're still very, very early in their digital transformation process, and that's because, again, the back office functions and organizations may not necessarily be seen as critical or on the critical path to the organization's success. And again, unfortunately, their initiatives, their projects, their modernization efforts get pushed year after year to the end of the line. DANNY BRADBURY: So, I guess, the frustrating thing about all this is that even if you do manage to get everyone on board, get the executive sponsorship and so on internally, that is often only the first part of the battle, isn't it? You've got two parties in a payment, of course. So if the supply chain doesn't cooperate, you're back to square one. Could you, Brandon, talk us through what happens when third parties don't cooperate with your plan? BRANDON SATHER: Yeah, thanks, Danny. I think internal alignment is a prerequisite for doing this well. But if you get internal alignment, it does not mean that these modernization efforts will be successful. I guess, it assumes that partners will come along for the ride. If you build a better mousetrap, they're going to come, but they don't always. I think some of the things that we've seen, where clients might launch a payment portal, or they'll launch some change in their payments, not all the suppliers are kicking down the door to come into another payment portal. Some are just going to say, kick rocks, send me a check, you know how to get me the check. I think that change management as part of this process has to be part of the plan from up front. So if you're endeavoring down the path of a modernization for your payments, you should let suppliers know. Let your strategic suppliers know ahead of time, hey, there's going to be some change coming, here's what we're considering, and you might have more success getting them aligned with your process. I think what we see is something, like 53% of vendors accept virtual cards on average, and that leaves room for improvement on the other 47%. And I think one way of getting that 47% is treating these strategic suppliers as part of the process. They have a stake in the process as well. And rather than just sending them an email with, hey, here's my new payments portal, here's my new process, I think the communication along the way can lead to some better change management with strategic suppliers. DANNY BRADBURY: Right, which comes back to the whole kind of vendor management argument, I guess. These people can't be dealt with at arm's length. They've got to be part of the process, and there has to be a fairly strong relationship. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Well, listen, thanks so much to both of you for walking us through this. It sounds like a great commercial opportunity for finance teams, if they can frame it properly and overcome some of the challenges we've talked about today. Now, I'd also like to hear from our audience. They've been diligently submitting questions, as we've been talking this through. So let's look at a couple of these. One here we have from someone, it says we've never baselined our AP functions. So where do we start? And, Anthony, I think I'm going to throw that one over to you. ANTHONY GRAYSON: Thanks, Barry. That's an outstanding question. I would position that and say, I would start with what I would call the discovery process, and from me personally, I would look at flow charting some of your core, let's say, account payable and payment processes. Flow chart those and understand what's the technology being used, the individuals that play a part of that process, and use that as a beginning. So start with the supplier onboarding process. Move kind of along that spectrum into the invoice receiving process, the invoice processing capabilities, and how that works within the organization, and then continuing to move left to right, flow charting the payment processes. What does that look like within our organization? Then I would wrap that up with, again, some of the ancillary types of things, like escheatment, potentially even tax, if that's attributable to your organization. Next, I would leverage the activity-based costing examples that Brandon referenced earlier, and then to those processes and to those functions, start to assign the cost. We understand the people that are involved in those processes. We understand the technology that's involved in those processes. So that really then becomes our baseline or our cost basis, if you will. At the same time, I would encourage the listener there to also identify bottlenecks. Identify pain points in your current process today, because ultimately, with any new process, whether it's a technology-based solution, we're going to look to work through that bottleneck, work through that pain point. But I think it's important that we understand those and where those lie within the organization. And then I always, always challenge organizations to think about, and I ask them when I'm engaged with them, what does the future state look like for this process? What does the payments process in a perfect world look like in your organization? Then that becomes the North Star. It provides us with a vision, and then from that vision, we can articulate the strategy and drive that down then into some of the technical and tactical things we need to undertake. DANNY BRADBURY: Excellent. Thanks, Anthony. And another one, I think, actually, you might be suited for here as well, we covered this a little bit in the talk, but I think this audience member wants a little more depth. They said, which benchmark sources should mid-market firms trust? This goes back to the metrics question. Maybe just a bit of a deeper dive on that. ANTHONY GRAYSON: Sure. I always encourage anyone to leverage your banking partners. They have a wealth of information in terms of your payment processes, your treasury processes, perhaps your carded processes as well. I would challenge them to help benchmark, how does my organization look across your portfolio, and how does my organization fare in terms of other clients that you may have that are similar industry or of similar size? Aside from that, then you can also leverage-- we mentioned earlier two organizations I'm very fond of. AFP and the APQC are outstanding organizations for providing detailed benchmarking and cost analysis for a broad spectrum of industry, whether it's the large market or the mid-market types of clients. So those are outstanding resources, but then I also encourage to make sure that you've done your due diligence. As you're calculating your benchmarks, I challenge you to think about, what are the assumptions that go into building any particular number, any particular KPI that you end up with? These are the assumptions that we included in that analysis, which I think will make then for a much richer and much deeper conversation when you do and are able to benchmark against other organizations. DANNY BRADBURY: Excellent. Good stuff. This next one, Brandon, I think, will be for you. You mentioned just back then that, I think, 47% of companies weren't using virtual cards yet. And someone has asked, how do we handle suppliers who refuse virtual cards? BRANDON SATHER: Yeah, it's a great question, and it's one we get quite a bit. I think for me, the place that I start is with a rigorous supplier segmentation, and you really want to understand who your strategic suppliers are versus your long tail suppliers. And so strategic doesn't necessarily mean frequency of payments or size of payments. It could be cogs, or it could be SG&A. But for your individual business, you need to understand which suppliers are core to the operation of my business and then focus there. You don't want to spend too much time trying to get card adoption from a vendor that you pay once a quarter for a very small amount. You can spend your time on your strategic suppliers, trying to get their acceptance. And acceptance, we know, is the top barrier cited for virtual cards. I think 34% of surveyed companies cite supplier resistance as one of the issues with virtual cards. And I think if segmenting into your strategic suppliers allows you to build a plan for change management, as I mentioned earlier, and this plan for change management should be part of the overall modernization implementation plan. It's not an afterthought of, cool, we did this great modernization exercise. Now, how do we get suppliers to accept card? That should be as part of the entire implementation. And I think there's a couple of things you can bring to the suppliers to show them what's in it for them. There's faster payment times, which turns into a real economic optionality for a supplier. You know, what's the value of getting your money 2, 3, 7, 10 days faster? And then also things, like if modernization, we now can deliver things directly into your ERPs or into your accounting systems. So what's the value of being able to accept a payment plus the data related to the payment at the same time? So I think broadly, tackling this supplier adoption piece is pretty tricky. But if you go at it with a rigorous plan of knowing who your targeted strategic suppliers are, how you're going to engage with them throughout your process, and how you can deliver them economic outcomes as part of it, I think the combination of those three things will drive some differentiated results. DANNY BRADBURY: Anthony, did you have anything else to add? ANTHONY GRAYSON: Yeah, Danny, just a thought. I think Brandon, spot on, again, with his answer here. I encourage in the conversations I have with buyers and suppliers to think about it from this perspective. Just as the buyer is looking to, let's say, leverage a virtual card solution, they're doing so for a reason. They're doing so, and it drives back to those four pillars that we spoke of. They're looking to drive efficiency into the organization. They're looking to drive economic value, unlock the value that's buried within some of their payment processes. I think the key point here is that the suppliers are looking for the exact same thing. The supplier's looking to drive efficiencies into their accounts receivable process. Just like we're looking to drive efficiencies into the payment processes, suppliers are looking to drive efficiencies into the receivables process, and they're looking to drive and generate economic benefit out of their receivables. And so to Brandon's point, the ability to expedite my payment that may have been, let's say, 45 days now to something that is 0 or 5 days, you've made a significant impact into that suppliers cash conversion cycle, and all of those things really help to drive that adoption and acceptance of the virtual card. DANNY BRADBURY: Good stuff. And I think we've got room for maybe one more question here. Brandon, I'm going to throw this one over to you. Again, it's on the virtual card side. Someone asks, are virtual cards expensive? BRANDON SATHER: Yeah, we get this a lot. I think this perception gap on the cost of a payment exists today. I think I mentioned earlier that virtual cards, on average, are a little over $7 fully loaded per transaction, where ACH is almost $9 fully loaded. So, objectively, no, virtual cards are not expensive, but we do have this perception gap. And I think to some of the conversation we've been having about planning for change management, doing all these things, delivering to Tony's point, what's in it for the supplier, I think you can overcome this perception of virtual cards are expensive by relaying the positives of virtual cards, both as a buyer and as a supplier. But I think that in general, no, virtual cards are not expensive or more expensive than other payment types. And in a lot of cases, they're cheaper, faster, and more appropriate. DANNY BRADBURY: Wonderful. OK, well, Brandon, Anthony, thank you again. It's been a great discussion, and I personally have learned a lot. The four pillars give financial teams a framework, I guess, for payment modernization. Brandon's cost analysis gives them defensible numbers. So together, they're the difference between a pitch that, I guess, lands properly with the CFO and with the vendors, and one that stalls at the gate. And to our attendees today, we hope you enjoyed this too. A recording will be available on demand. Find U.S. Bank's commercial payment solutions at the link in the chat. ©2026 U.S. Bank. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owner.