0:00 Today we're talking about private capital, direct 0:02 investments, and alternatives as it applies to families in 0:05 their long term portfolios. 0:07 We've seen over the last few years, families are pivoting 0:09 from looking at stocks and bonds and traditional 0:12 forms of investment to alternatives such as private capital, 0:15 direct investing, private credit, and others. 0:18 With those types of investments comes increasing complexity, 0:21 finding the deals. 0:22 Understanding the deals, 0:24 researching the deals, 0:25 structuring those deals. 0:27 So as we move through this into more of the capital markets, 0:31 we really wanted to talk with 0:33 Cash A Min who's joined us. 0:34 Kosh is our head of private markets for US Bank. 0:37 He essentially founded. 0:38 The private capital effort for US Bank and works a lot with 0:42 ultra high net worth clients to help them understand what 0:45 those investments are, 0:46 how they can be structured into their portfolio to create 0:50 better risk adjusted long-term returns. 0:52 So Kash, welcome. 0:53 Glad to have you here. 0:54 Tell us a little bit about your background. 0:56 Sure, John. 0:57 So I joined US Bank in 2016, as you pointed out, helped set 1:00 this program, 1:02 um, and since then we've made significant progress. 1:04 Prior to that, I was with the private equity fund of funds. 1:08 called Fort Washington and then way back when 1:12 I'm trained as a computer scientist. 1:14 Uh, which, which a lot of people find surprising when they 1:16 hear about it, but then 1:19 started initially as an engineer and then transitioned to, 1:22 uh, 1:23 working at Fidelity Ventures 1:26 in their Boston office. 1:27 So, I did that for about 7 years 1:30 before I went back to business school and, and then since 1:32 then, I've been in, in private equity and so I've been in 1:35 private markets for about 25 years now. 1:38 And uh I've seen a lot. 1:40 I've seen lots of different market regimes. 1:44 I've seen um new technology cycles come and go, 1:49 uh, but yeah, we've experienced quite a bit and uh we do 1:52 some very interesting stuff out here. 1:54 Yeah, I, I dabbled in private equity a little bit, had my 1:57 own firm for a few years, and 1:58 find it to be a really good way to invest. 2:00 It's much more. 2:02 In depth 2:03 because it's a long term investment, so you got to be sure, 2:06 um, but before we dive too much into the, into the private 2:09 capital, 2:10 we think about alternatives and that seems to be what is a 2:13 very broad category. 2:15 How do you think about alternatives? 2:17 How can we kind of frame that up for our listeners? 2:20 Yeah, traditionally alternatives have been a bucket which 2:24 captured everything that did not fit the traditional, 2:28 you know, asset classes, right? 2:29 Your traditional stocks, your bonds, 2:32 anything that's publicly traded, 2:36 not publicly traded rather, and outside of that realm of 2:39 stocks and bonds. 2:40 Was captured by alternatives 2:43 and that also includes hedge funds. 2:45 It includes, um, you know, exchange funds. 2:49 Uh, it also includes a category we'll talk about later which 2:52 is impact investing. 2:53 Yeah, we'll come back to that in. 2:56 That's right. 2:56 So it's a very broad swath of, um, 3:00 um, you know, different exposures which don't fall within 3:03 the traditional buckets. 3:05 And private markets is one of the big categories within 3:07 that. 3:08 Has it consolidated around anything, because I think of an 3:10 ETF as a security, 3:12 but is that still considered an alternative, or what that 3:14 ETF invests in is the alternative? 3:17 Yeah, 3:17 ETF would still be considered to be more traditional, right? 3:21 Um, and then if the ETF has exposure to something which is 3:24 non-traditional, which 3:26 we don't see as much, 3:28 there are mutual funds that have exposure to or alternative. 3:32 Mutual funds, which, 3:34 uh, you know, you would think like mutual funds are 3:35 traditional 3:37 categories, asset categories, but 3:39 Uh, there are alternative mutual funds, but again, those are 3:42 more liquid options. 3:44 But ETFs are more traditional 3:46 exposure to the public markets. 3:48 Got it. 3:49 OK, so let's go to your area of expertise for a quarter of a 3:52 century if I heard you correctly. 3:53 That's right. 3:54 Um, 3:54 what is private capital? 3:57 So private capital, 3:59 you know, broadly speaking, is 4:01 accessing capital or 4:03 markets which are not publicly traded. 4:06 So these are investments which are not listed on a stock 4:09 exchange 4:11 or cannot be accessed through, you know, traditional routes, 4:14 and 4:16 it captures everything from private credit, it captures real 4:20 assets like real estate investments, 4:22 or it could be 4:23 investments in 4:25 farmland. 4:25 It could be exposure to timber. 4:28 And then it also includes private equity. 4:31 It includes venture capital, 4:34 um, growth equity. 4:35 So, when you think about venture capital, that is the early 4:38 stage of a company's formation, 4:40 and that is a category in itself. 4:42 And then private equity is more 4:45 in, more 4:46 oriented towards mature companies, which have been 4:50 operational for a while and are, 4:51 are more stable in terms of operations and, you know, growth 4:54 has slowed down. 4:56 So it's a very broad category 4:58 and um 5:00 you know there's um it's a significant portion of the US 5:02 economy and global economy in general. 5:05 OK, so 5:06 taking it down a level, there's multiple risks and benefits 5:09 associated with, with private capital investing. 5:12 Talk a little bit about those and how we should be thinking 5:14 about that and then in, you know, in terms of our 5:17 portfolios, but also in just what are the risks and 5:20 benefits associated with it. 5:22 Yes, so the risks are multivariate, and what I mean by that 5:25 is that 5:28 It, it, it, you know, the biggest risk factor when you 5:31 invest in this category, I would say is the liquidity risk, 5:35 which is when you invest in this, 5:37 your capital 5:39 tends to be locked up 5:41 longer than you otherwise would if you invested in, in like 5:45 an ETF or a mutual fund. 5:48 So, 5:49 so that illiquid nature of this asset category means that 5:52 you cannot easily go in and out of, of that investment, 5:57 which means that you need to get compensated for that, 5:59 right? 5:59 For holding something which is relatively illiquid because 6:03 if you needed access to your capital, 6:05 it's not something you can just tap into immediately. 6:08 So that is one. 6:09 The other thing is also, it depends on what stage of company 6:13 formation you invest. 6:14 If you're investing in a venture, 6:16 which is very early, it could just be an idea, a product 6:20 concept, 6:22 and it's still not, 6:23 you know, 6:24 commercial, as in, it doesn't have revenues, 6:27 right? 6:27 So that business might still not have revenues. 6:29 It's just 6:30 a solution which has potential for future growth. 6:35 So, 6:35 at that stage, it's a very 6:38 significant binary risk, um, 6:40 you know, it can be complete zero, right? 6:42 Like the investment could, you know, 6:45 basically be 6:46 a complete write-off or 6:49 it could lead to something like, you know, most recently 6:52 SpaceX, which is a huge, 6:54 huge outcome. 6:56 So, um, 6:57 so it varies depending on 6:59 Where you are in that spectrum of that company's life cycle, 7:02 right, when you invest. 7:04 Now, private credit has lower risk compared to venture. 7:08 Real assets similarly has lower risk compared to venture or 7:12 private equity because you're holding a real asset which 7:15 has, 7:16 you know, 7:16 inherent value to it. 7:19 So again, it's, it's a, 7:21 as I said, it's multivariate, it's quite wide, and it's very 7:24 important that you underwrite that specific 7:27 situation. 7:27 Yeah, 7:28 and we've talked about this in the past. 7:29 I've been both a public and a private investor over my 7:32 career. 7:33 And I've looked at public investing as being dating. 7:37 Private investing as being a marriage 7:39 because it's, it's, you know, dating, you can just sell it, 7:41 you make a mistake in a, in a public stock and you just sell 7:43 it and move on. 7:44 You make a mistake in a private capital stock, and it's not 7:47 easy to unwind that position. 7:49 Is that a fair, 7:51 that's spot on, and I've used that analogy quite frequently 7:54 we're. 7:56 Where if you are in the public markets, you can, you know, 8:00 invest in something. 8:02 It's cheap to actually invest in like an ETF or a mutual 8:05 fund. 8:06 You know, uh, 8:07 these days the commission structures are quite, 8:09 you know, 8:10 it's actually, you know, pretty much cents on the dollar, 8:13 right, 8:13 exactly. 8:15 Versus with private markets, it's expensive, you know, 8:19 these, uh, the fees are high, 8:21 uh, finding these opportunities is difficult. 8:24 So, that analogy really sticks and especially 8:29 within private markets, you're getting in for the long term. 8:32 So, you have to have that view that 8:34 I'm investing for the long term and for growth. 8:38 And if you bring that analogy full circle, 8:42 Um, you know, getting married is expensive and actually 8:47 unwinding that is also very expensive. 8:49 And the same thing applies here, so you have to be very 8:51 careful going 8:52 in. 8:52 So you've taken it to the illogical extreme. 8:54 I like that. 8:55 All right, so, 8:56 when we 8:57 look at this through the lens of legacy, which is the title 9:00 of this series, how do you think about private capital 9:03 investing relative to, 9:04 uh, uh, an ultra affluent family's portfolio in long term? 9:08 How do, how do you fit all that together? 9:10 I think for ultra high net worth families, 9:13 um, 9:14 especially for families that are looking for 9:17 growth 9:18 and even their portfolios, want to leave a legacy, 9:22 um, you know, for whatever reason, for their beneficiaries 9:25 or it could be broadly through philanthropic, you know, 9:29 goals that they have. 9:30 It's an important aspect or allocation that they should 9:34 consider within their portfolios because this is where. 9:38 You know, 9:38 if you just talk about the access to the broader 9:42 set of the economy, US economy, you cannot get that through 9:45 traditional means, 9:47 which is, 9:47 it's a significant portion of that, you know, broad 9:50 economic 9:52 engine, 9:52 right? 9:53 So, 9:54 to give you a statistic, about 8, 90% of, 9:58 actually, it's 80%. 10:00 Of US businesses that have $100 million in revenue and above 10:05 are privately held 80%, 80%. 10:08 OK, 10:08 I was unaware of that. 10:09 That's 10:10 like stuff that's a huge number. 10:12 And, and you don't get access to that if you invest through 10:15 traditional stocks and bonds. 10:17 I think most 10:17 people look at CNBC or they look at their 10:20 401k and you know, I don't know how big the, the US equity 10:23 market is, the global equity market in the trillions of 10:25 dollars. 10:26 And the private market is 4 times that size on the outside 10:29 of it. 10:30 That's, that's fascinating. 10:31 I didn't 10:31 know that. 10:32 Yeah, 10:33 in terms of the companies that are held, 10:35 uh, privately, right? 10:36 Yes, 10:37 um, 10:37 but the amount of capital that has been invested is still a 10:42 very small portion of the overall investment capital. 10:45 So the number of companies, 10:46 the size of the investments is small. 10:48 And those are owned by individuals like founders and 10:50 operated by them. 10:53 But, uh, so that is one reason, so you want that exposure 10:56 within a portfolio for ultra high net worth families. 11:00 But also, to my point, if you want to um enable growth 11:04 within the portfolio, leave a legacy, 11:06 it's important to have an allocation because this is where 11:10 a lot of growth happens. 11:12 Um, as an example, 11:14 again, bringing it back to SpaceX, which is the most obvious 11:17 these days, like that company listed at 1.75 trillion. 11:23 All of that valuation pre-IPO happened in the private 11:27 markets. 11:27 So the growth, 11:29 significant growth happened 11:30 while it was private. 11:32 So which means if you want exposure to that sort of growth, 11:35 you have to be invested in private markets. 11:39 So that's a very big reason why, and as long as 11:44 families have that ability to sustain long term viewpoint. 11:49 Then it's an important category. 11:51 So is, 11:52 so 11:53 when the tip of the iceberg argument is we can see a little 11:56 bit of the value, but you don't know what's under the water, 11:58 particularly the SpaceX, 12:00 because it's, it, it doesn't mark to market. 12:02 You don't see it. 12:02 It's not a ticker. 12:04 So once it goes public, then all of a sudden you see, wow, 12:06 there's a massive valuation here that, that was under the 12:09 surface, 12:10 and that's 12:11 where you really make 12:12 the money in private capital. 12:14 Yeah, I, I mean, 12:16 you know. 12:17 Netflix listed in 2003, I believe, 12:20 at $300 million valuation. 12:23 So you compare that to what's coming next with anthropic 12:26 OpenAI. 12:27 We are talking about $1 trillion valuations, right? 12:30 Or listings. 12:32 So back in the day, growth used to happen in the public 12:34 markets. 12:36 Companies used to list publicly earlier in their life cycle. 12:40 That has completely flipped, 12:42 where majority of the growth now happens while the companies 12:45 are private 12:46 and then post IPO, you, you know, 12:50 a lot of that growth has been captured in the valuation. 12:53 So. 12:54 So, it's a, you know, again, it comes back to, um, and for a 12:58 variety of reasons why these companies are staying private 13:00 longer, we can get into that, but 13:03 it's just that, that's the nature of the current 13:05 um 13:06 structure of the markets. 13:08 And, uh, you know, it's important that, 13:10 you know, again, investors have exposure to that. 13:14 Cool. 13:14 So, um, 13:16 without going too far down the rabbit hole in this, when we 13:18 look at the investment in a private capital, 13:20 you hear this spooky thing called the J curve. 13:23 So there's a certain amount of time where 13:26 cash flows are gonna be negative and 13:28 explain that because I think that may be off-putting to 13:30 folks because they don't realize how 13:32 that structure works. 13:34 Yeah, so the J curve is uh 13:37 when you invest in a, 13:39 in a private equity fund, 13:41 what happens is early in the life cycle, 13:45 um, 13:46 you know, as the, as the funds are deployed, 13:49 you know, you, you don't still see the markups or the, or 13:52 the company that they buy, the private equity, uh, you know, 13:56 investors when they buy these companies. 13:58 They hold it at cost, at least for the 1st year and the 2nd 14:02 year until they start seeing 14:04 operational benefits come through. 14:06 And, and during that time period, 14:08 while they're investing, they're still charging fees 14:11 on, on, on the committed capital, 14:14 and we can get into what committed means. 14:16 So committed, you know, essentially is 14:19 if you commit to a fund, 14:21 you're committing a certain amount, which eventually will be 14:24 drawn down to invest in these companies. 14:27 So there are fees being charged while the initial portfolio 14:31 is being built out. 14:32 So during that transition period, 14:34 you see the value of your investment actually dip down below 14:38 your cost of, you know, 14:39 investment or, or your principal. 14:43 And that can be 14:44 a little bit disconcerting for investors who are new to this 14:47 category, right? 14:48 Because they see 14:50 uh this was supposed to be. 14:52 A growth investment than I was expected to make, you know, 14:55 20% IRRs. 14:57 What's happening in the first two years? 14:58 Why is it not moving? 15:00 And, and, and that's part of like the 15:03 education process for new investors. 15:06 Like this is very typical 15:07 and it's expected during the initial period, but then 15:11 eventually 15:12 it makes up in spades. 15:13 OK, 15:14 so when you think about private equity, private capital 15:17 relative to an ultra-high net worth portfolio, how does it 15:19 fit? 15:20 How do you size it? 15:21 How, how do you think about it? 15:23 Um, 15:24 yeah, 15:25 it's a, it's an art and science, and it varies by 15:30 individual, 15:31 um, 15:32 goals as well as risk, you know, 15:35 factors, and, you know, 15:37 uh, so it, it varies quite a bit from, you know, client to 15:40 client to portfolio to 15:41 portfolio. 15:42 So if you've seen one private equity investment, you've seen 15:44 one private equity investment in the portfolio. 15:47 Got it. 15:47 But it varies because it, so our approach is typically, 15:51 again, take into consideration what the goals are for the 15:54 client, 15:55 um, how much are they able to bear that illiquid aspect of 15:59 that, you know, category 16:01 within private markets. 16:03 And then based on that, our 16:05 typical recommendation for long term growth oriented 16:07 portfolios is anywhere from 15 to 20% allocation, 16:12 big chunk. 16:12 It's a big chunk, 16:13 and, and 16:15 again goes back to all the reasons why, you know, I 16:17 expressed that, you know, why you should be exposed to that 16:20 specific 16:21 category. 16:21 So if somebody has a $100 million portfolio, they've got 16:24 plenty of cash flow to take care of their 16:26 day to day living expenses, their liquidity is taken care 16:28 of. 16:29 And you allocate in this case, 15 to 20 million 16:32 into this, which is going to go away for a while, 16:35 but it's going to compound at a very handsome return. 16:36 Is that how you're thinking about it? 16:37 Exactly, 16:38 exactly. 16:39 So, 16:39 the goal of this, this portion of the allocation is to 16:42 compound at significantly higher returns 16:46 than what you can earn within public markets, 16:49 and that has been the case over the last 2030 years. 16:52 Um, having said that, most recently, S&P has done extremely 16:55 well. 16:56 But 16:57 we've seen those periods in the past where S&P 17:01 just continues to rally 17:03 and eventually though, it does revert back to the long-term 17:07 average returns. 17:10 And, and then you compare that to again longer time frames 17:12 for private markets, they have continued to outperform, 17:15 uh, 17:16 the rooting for 17:18 that. 17:18 We're not rooting for that. 17:19 We're not 17:21 exactly. 17:21 We're not rooting for that, but it's just the nature of 17:24 how, you know, 17:26 the market cycles work 17:28 and you know, it's good to be aware and, and rather than, 17:32 um, just hope for the best, right? 17:34 Like, and, you know, obviously. 17:36 History doesn't repeat all the time, but it does rhyme, 17:40 and you, you have to pay attention to like the previous 17:43 experience and how 17:45 valuations are trending and 17:47 um a lot of other factors. 17:49 So 17:50 in the families that you work with, are you finding there to 17:53 be more or less about the same amount of interest in private 17:55 capital? 17:56 How are, are people becoming 17:59 most of the families we work with tend to be first 18:01 generation wealth, so they're not, you know, they've been 18:02 head down building their business. 18:04 And they've not been exposed to this, so people, 18:06 where are people's minds on 18:08 this? 18:09 Yeah, I saw a recent research that was conducted on um 18:13 from one of our peers actually that, that looked into all 18:17 the different 18:19 cohorts of wealth cohorts 18:21 and across the board, there was more appreciation of private 18:26 markets that 18:27 if they did not have exposure to private markets, they 18:30 wanted to actually start 18:32 getting exposure. 18:33 And for those who already did, 18:36 they, they had conviction in continuing that, that 18:39 investment, you know, category. 18:42 So, 18:43 net net, the trend is from across different client cohorts, 18:47 as well as across demographics. 18:51 Uh, there is a lot of interest within this category, 18:54 and we expect that to continue to grow. 18:56 Yeah, I wanna, and we're gonna get to the environment here 18:59 in a couple of minutes, so I, I wanna, there's a couple of 19:01 things I want to drill down on there. 19:02 Um, let's pivot real quick to direct investing. 19:05 Direct investing is different from private capital 19:08 investing, but it is a subset thereof, I would assume. 19:11 How do you think about direct investing? 19:13 So, direct investing essentially is directly investing in, 19:17 in a company, 19:18 uh, versus 19:20 investing in a fund that, 19:22 that in turn invests in a company. 19:24 So there are two ways of accessing private markets. 19:28 You can either directly invest in a company or invest 19:31 through a fund structure. 19:33 And direct investing has gained momentum, 19:36 especially for ascent-level clients, 19:40 where, you know, they want to actually get closer 19:43 to the, to the underlying portfolio company than 19:46 used to be the case in the past. 19:48 Uh, it, it, it is a category which we are also, you know, 19:53 planning to focus on. 19:55 Having said that, it comes with a different set of 19:57 considerations. 19:59 And um 20:00 the main consideration is if you're investing in one company 20:03 versus through a fund, 20:06 you are exposed to that one company and you're not as 20:09 diversified as you would be if you invested through a fund. 20:13 So that is a big factor. 20:15 And that company can have its own set of risks and 20:19 challenges. 20:20 Um, so, you know, 20:23 this is a category which needs to be approached with even 20:25 more caution 20:26 and, and care 20:28 than, um, 20:30 private markets in general, which 20:32 also need extreme caution and care, 20:34 but this is a step level above, you know, in terms of how 20:36 cautious 20:38 one should be when investing in, in a company directly. 20:40 So if a family has an expertise in a certain vertical, 20:43 pick your, pick your vertical, 20:45 they may have an advantage and be able to identify. 20:48 Opportunities 20:50 at a, at a better rate. 20:51 What, what, 20:53 what, when I think about 20:54 what you do as a direct 20:56 investor, 20:57 you have to source, 20:58 you have to diligence, you have to structure and you have to 21:00 exit, 21:01 and each one of those is a discipline and an expertise. 21:05 And 21:06 it's, it's a stretch to say a lot of people have that. 21:09 And so putting your money into the private capital funds, 21:12 yeah, you're paying for it, but you get all that expertise 21:14 within that. 21:15 Is that 21:15 exactly, 21:17 exactly. 21:17 Now a family might have, as you pointed out, 21:20 an um, 21:22 background in a specific category 21:24 that they, you know, 21:26 that's how they grew their legacy and their, 21:29 uh, wealth. 21:30 So, they might be inclined to continue to invest within that 21:34 category through other direct investments. 21:37 But again, it takes, 21:39 you know, a different set of skill sets. 21:41 So they would need that in-house to be able to execute on 21:44 something like that. 21:45 In terms of, you know, first of all, sourcing those 21:48 companies, right? 21:49 That's a big 21:50 ask in itself, 21:52 um, finding the right situation where the seller is 21:56 interested in actually selling that asset 21:58 or, or taking in new capital. 22:01 And then to your point, structuring that deal effectively, 22:04 making sure that they have the right set of protections. 22:07 If they are coming in as a minority investor, 22:10 then do you have enough control over the asset or the 22:13 company. 22:14 Such that you can drive some outcomes. 22:17 Um, 22:17 and 22:18 also if you wanted to exit in the future or sell that 22:22 company in the future or that position. 22:24 If you are a minority holder, then do you have that rights 22:28 baked in 22:29 into the structure itself when you go in. 22:32 Now, it gets very complicated and I, 22:34 you know, 22:35 I just want to make sure we don't get into 22:37 extreme nuances out here, but it, it, it, it does 22:41 require a very special set of expertise 22:44 and it's not easy to, 22:45 to do, 22:47 um, 22:48 as well as running that business if you have control 22:50 position. 22:51 You need someone to operate that business. 22:53 So you are responsible for hiring, firing, 22:56 setting strategy. 22:58 You become an operator. 22:59 So you are 23:01 very hands-on. 23:03 As I, as I think about that, 23:05 just, I mean, 23:06 it's, it's expensive to invest in private capital, we know 23:09 that, 23:10 but just think of the attorney's fees. 23:12 investment, I mean, that's gonna be 23:15 everything's expensive, yeah, yeah, 23:16 just like getting married. 23:17 It's very 23:18 all of it is very expensive. 23:20 Um, 23:21 so there's attorney fees, there's transaction costs like the 23:24 bank, there might be a banker 23:25 involved. 23:26 They charge anywhere from 3 to 6% points on, on the 23:29 transaction itself. 23:31 Then you 23:32 you're getting into private capital fees 23:35 without the insulation protection and diversification, more 23:37 importantly, 23:38 that's right. 23:38 So you're getting into all of those costs. 23:41 And things that there might be other costs that might show 23:43 up which you have not even anticipated, right, like holding 23:46 that company directly, 23:48 and I keep going back to this point about having sector 23:52 expertise. 23:53 Now again, some families might have that, 23:55 but do they really want to actually be that involved 23:59 in the day to day operations, right? 24:02 So unless they have someone on the staff to do that, 24:04 it's extremely difficult to pull it off. 24:06 Yeah, and I would think in having 24:08 Been exposed to this world for a long time that all that 24:10 shines is not gold. 24:11 That's right. 24:12 There's a lot of things that sound really cool. 24:14 But if you don't do your diligence, you can get, yeah, 24:17 I have another analogy for you. 24:19 So we talk about, 24:21 we talk about being very selective in how we approach this 24:24 space, and there's a reason for it, 24:26 because there's a wide dispersion in, in outcomes to your 24:29 point, not everything shines as gold. 24:32 The other analogy we use is that we kiss a lot of frogs to 24:35 find the prince. 24:36 Um, there are lots of other, I mean, there are a lot of 24:40 opportunities any given year. 24:42 There are about 3000. 24:44 Private capital funds that raised every single year, 24:48 uh, they raise capital every year. 24:49 So, out of those 3000, 24:51 um, only a few might be actually worth their, 24:55 uh, 24:56 uh, worth, worth their weight in, 24:59 you know, 24:59 gold, if you will. 25:01 Um, but, so you have to be extremely selective going in and, 25:04 and finding those nuggets, if you will. 25:07 Um, so, 25:08 same thing applies for direct investing across the board. 25:11 Uh, one of the issues with this category is that information 25:14 is proprietary. 25:15 So 25:16 if I'm looking to find information, 25:19 I have to, 25:20 it, it's, it's not something I can go to 25:23 a website to find information won't have it, 25:26 right? 25:26 Morningstar won't have it. 25:27 It won't be on Bloomberg. 25:29 It won't be on, 25:30 you know, Wall Street Journal or any of that. 25:32 This is all held very closely by the, 25:35 by the owner 25:36 of that's their 25:37 proprietary sauce, proprietary secret sauce. 25:40 There is no requirement for filing with SEC, right? 25:43 So, 25:43 so they don't have a requirement to file their 25:46 uh financials with SEC. 25:48 So those financials are very closely held. 25:51 So, to get access to that 25:53 itself is, is very difficult to begin with. 25:56 So, that makes it even more challenging that you're working 26:00 with imperfect information 26:02 and, and you have to get that information through 26:05 relationship building 26:07 and, and being in front of that, 26:09 that, 26:10 you know, seller or investor 26:12 and, and getting access to that information, 26:14 which we used to utilize 26:17 to actually do our analysis of like, is this a good 26:20 opportunity or not. 26:21 And 26:22 if you look at the outcomes, there's a very wide dispersion 26:26 in terms of the good and, and the not so good, 26:29 right? 26:30 And it's easy to say that 26:33 I'm a private equity investor, 26:35 but it's extremely difficult to actually deliver 26:37 to be a successful private equity, 26:40 correct. 26:40 So anyone can put up a shingle and say we are private equity 26:42 investors, 26:44 but are they really, right? 26:45 Like are they good at it? 26:47 And there are some really good investors, and then there's 26:51 The rest of them. 26:52 Well, let's, let's, 26:54 so we've kind of covered, well, we have covered private 26:56 capital and we're covered direct investing. 26:58 If we step back up because it's what I'm hearing, 27:01 so there were 3000 private equity funds, so you're kissing 27:03 2990 to get to the 10, right? 27:06 I mean, that's, so it's a lot of chapstick. 27:08 So if we look at the macro environment, 27:11 what's going on with private equity? 27:13 There seems to be a lot of capital flowing into this space, 27:16 and 27:17 you, you see a lot of 27:19 capital need out there. 27:21 Or is there a disequilibrium there? 27:22 I mean, what do you, what are the macro things you're seeing 27:24 in the market right now? 27:26 You know, there has been more interest over the 27:30 last 27:31 decade. 27:31 It has been picking up within 27:33 for private market investing, right? 27:36 So what happens when that, 27:38 when there's more interest, there's more capital that goes 27:41 into that category. 27:42 Inefficiencies 27:43 evaporated. 27:45 Well, 27:46 to a certain extent, 27:47 and the reason for that is that information is still um. 27:52 You know, 27:53 so inefficient information which allows the 27:56 inefficiencies to remain exploited by foreign investors. 27:59 Exactly. 28:00 So the information asymmetry still exists, 28:03 but there is more capital that has gone into the category. 28:07 Having said that, as I mentioned, companies are staying 28:09 private even longer, 28:11 so they are funding their growth in private markets versus 28:16 going public. 28:17 So all that capital 28:19 again. 28:19 To pick off, you know, these three names which are in the 28:22 zeitgeist these days, right? 28:24 Like, 28:25 uh, Anthropic most recently 28:27 financed $80 billion in private markets. 28:31 This was unheard of 28:33 back in the day 28:34 to finance even 28:36 $10 million was extremely difficult. 28:39 So you would be forced to go to a public to a public market, 28:43 but now you're not forced to do that. 28:45 You can do. 28:47 Your financing within the private, 28:48 so 28:48 there's more capital available so you don't have to go 28:51 public. 28:51 You can keep it within the private 28:53 and then make the big SpaceX anthropic splash. 28:55 That's right. 28:56 Got it. 28:57 So, but, but that what that does is also that a lot of 29:02 traditional investors don't have access to 29:05 the companies before they go public. 29:08 So that is something that needs to be solved, right, 29:11 because 29:11 again this is where a lot of money is 29:13 being made when you say solved. 29:15 It's a problem to be solved or an inefficiency to be 29:18 exploited by smart investors. 29:20 It is an inefficiency right now, 29:22 but if you just talk about the general good, right, 29:25 it's a, it's a problem to be solved because, you know, 29:28 if I could invest in Netflix in 2003 and 29:32 see my money grow, like, you know, 29:34 4,000%. 29:37 Now you don't have that opportunity, right, because these 29:40 companies invested in technology so that tells you where I'm 29:43 at. 29:44 So 29:46 yeah, 29:46 so they, you know, 29:47 you don't, in traditional investors don't have that sort of 29:51 access. 29:51 So from a general good standpoint, you know, that is 29:54 something that needs to be 29:55 solved, but it also creates opportunity for 29:59 investors, uh, like our clients that can, you know, 30:02 invest in private markets. 30:03 They have access to that kind of stuff. 30:05 What are things that an ultra-affluent family should be 30:08 listening for, should be thinking about 30:11 with regard to private capital? 30:13 Are there headlines that are out there that should grab them 30:15 to say, I want to drill down on this particular topic. 30:18 I think the first step is to understand what it means, you 30:21 know, as, you know, private capital, what does it mean? 30:23 What are the categories? 30:26 Um, you know, what should, 30:28 what should they be aware of in terms of 30:31 the risk involved, 30:33 but also understand that 30:36 not everything 30:37 that says private markets or private capital is equal. 30:40 There is a big, big difference 30:43 in terms of 30:44 what is good and what isn't, you know, the rest, right, as 30:47 we spoke earlier. 30:49 So they should be extremely careful about picking the right. 30:53 A partner to invest with and 30:56 seek expert advice, 30:58 look for 30:59 previous track record and history of doing it effectively. 31:03 So I think those are all very important considerations. 31:06 What are 31:06 a couple of questions 31:08 investors should ask their 31:09 providers or looking for providers. 31:12 The question they should be asking is, you know, what's the 31:15 skill set, right, of the people who are running that program 31:19 within that provider. 31:21 What's their history? 31:22 What's their background? 31:24 Uh, 31:24 can they look at their previous track record of actually 31:27 doing that work and what kind of outcomes have they seen 31:30 with them? 31:31 So those are very important questions to ask, and 31:35 You know, a provider can say like they're doing private 31:37 markets. 31:38 Anyone can say that, but to really do it effectively, where 31:41 it delivers the value, 31:43 you need a certain set of expertise, which they should make 31:46 sure that that provider has that. 31:48 It seems that in this market, in the private capital market, 31:52 that past performance is more indicative 31:55 of future performance than it is in just about any other 31:57 business because there's, 31:58 they're not tethered to the big macro stuff as much. 32:01 They're looking at a certain vertical or a certain sector, 32:04 and they're investing in that. 32:05 And if they've done it well for 20 years, it's pretty likely 32:07 they'll 32:08 do it well going forward. 32:09 Is that a fair assessment? 32:11 To a certain extent it is 32:13 within sector expertise matters. 32:16 Like if they are experts within a sector and if they have 32:19 evidence of execution and 32:21 Um, have delivered good performance, then yes, 32:24 it's an indication of 32:26 they do have that capability. 32:28 But broadly speaking, 32:29 you can pick a fund 32:31 that had 32:32 previously delivered good outcomes, 32:34 but now that fund might have grown 32:37 to 3 or 4 times the size, 32:40 and they have moved into a different category completely. 32:43 So you cannot rely 32:44 on that. 32:44 So the $10 million investment to have the same effect has to 32:47 be a $100 million investment now, and those are fewer and 32:49 farther between. 32:49 Exactly. 32:50 Got it. 32:50 So you have to be, you know, 32:53 again, how you look at that history and track record is 32:56 important. 32:57 But, 32:58 you know, as far as our clients go for them, what matters is 33:01 that, 33:02 you know, does the provider have the right people in the 33:05 seat 33:06 that are providing these investments? 33:09 What is their history? 33:10 What's their background? 33:11 How have they done historically? 33:14 And are they, 33:15 you know, do they have some 33:17 good thought capital of how to 33:20 invest going forward, not just look back and say like that's 33:23 what we did 33:24 and we'll keep doing the same thing because markets are 33:26 always evolving, right? 33:28 So you have to make sure that they're hearing that sort of, 33:32 um, 33:33 viewpoint from their provider that. 33:36 We did this in the past, but that might not work in the 33:39 future, and here's where we are going next. 33:42 So it's a combination of all those things. 33:44 Are you seeing anything 33:46 particularly interesting going on, any trends emerging that, 33:49 that you're focusing on? 33:51 Yeah, so currently, so we have a very thematic approach on 33:55 how we invest in private markets, to my point that I 33:57 mentioned that 33:58 You know, things constantly change, right? 34:01 Markets evolve, 34:02 the structure of the markets change. 34:04 Private markets evolve. 34:06 So we cannot just 34:08 continue to do what we did in the past. 34:09 We are looking at 5 years, 10 years out in the future 34:13 and trying to understand where the, 34:15 where the trends are. 34:17 So what we do is we, 34:19 we do extensive work on, on, on, on thematic 34:23 views. 34:24 So we established, like we take into consideration capital 34:27 markets, 34:29 secular trends, any sort of demographic changes, 34:32 and then come up with what we call as our thesis. 34:35 So these thesis drive our investments in the future. 34:38 We see opportunities within 34:40 like aerospace and defense that continues to be a secular 34:43 trend. 34:44 We see opportunities within need for more power 34:48 within venture capital. 34:49 We see opportunities 34:51 to invest in. 34:52 In the future, 34:54 applications 34:55 that will use AI, 34:57 not just the models, but, you know, the applications that 35:00 will use AI. 35:02 In real assets, real estate, we see 35:05 pockets where we want to deploy capital, such as 35:09 the Midwest markets in, in multi-family. 35:13 So, again, we have these very, 35:15 um, 35:16 very pointed views that we express, 35:18 and, and we try to see where the, where the buck is going. 35:22 And we, 35:22 you know, there will be opportunities continuing from here, 35:25 and we just have to make sure that 35:27 we find them. 35:29 What should families be thinking about? 35:31 I mean, what are their, uh, how should they, they're, 35:34 they're gonna come to you and say, gosh, I'm really thinking 35:36 about this. 35:37 What, what are the couple of things they should be 35:39 focusing on and I'm, you know, with regard to their 35:41 portfolio construction and just all that kind of stuff. 35:45 You know, again, I, I would emphasize that ask those 35:48 questions about 35:49 um 35:50 do you have that expertise to start with? 35:53 Show me evidence of that expertise, 35:55 um, 35:56 find out like who those people are who are actually finding, 35:59 coming up with these investments for you. 36:02 And then 36:03 think about, 36:04 you know, for your portfolios, what your objectives are from 36:08 a 36:09 growth standpoint, legacy standpoint, 36:12 um, and then obviously ask your advisor, how does it all 36:15 fit, 36:16 uh, within that context, right? 36:18 If I do invest in private markets, how does it fit within 36:21 that context? 36:22 But it's 36:23 investing is a zero-sum game. 36:24 I mean, you want the pie to grow, but the pie has to be 36:26 divided. 36:27 You got to make sure that you 36:29 take care of 36:30 lifestyle and liquidity and other 36:32 stuff, precisely, yeah, you have, you know, you, you have X 36:35 number of chips, right? 36:37 You have to allocate those chips, 36:39 and, um, you know, you have to think about, you know, which 36:43 is going where and what is the purpose of that. 36:46 So you have to like put all that into context and obviously 36:48 work with the experts within. 36:51 Uh, we have our, um, 36:53 uh, investment consulting 36:55 team that helps clients actually work through all of that. 36:59 But then also 37:00 make sure to ask like if they do recommend like invest in 37:03 private markets, get to know the team behind it, 37:06 who's investing that, and, and how are they coming up with 37:09 these ideas. 37:10 So all that is very important. 37:13 Well as we 37:14 bring this home, the what I'm hearing you say is. 37:17 Private capital is a very important asset class. 37:21 It's an asset class that has a lot of applications for the 37:23 ultra affluent. 37:25 It's not without its risks. 37:27 It's not without its illiquidity, meaning capital is gonna 37:30 be tied up for a while, 37:31 and you really need to find a team 37:33 that has your best interest at heart and is, is got the 37:36 expertise to bring it. 37:38 Is that, 37:39 yeah, 37:39 precisely captured. 37:40 This is not something you can go on. 37:43 Not, not to say anything bad about Robinhood, but Robinhood 37:46 is like, you know, a broker, right? 37:48 Like you can, it's an app where you can actually trade in 37:50 stocks. 37:51 This is not something you can do 37:53 directly on your own. 37:54 It requires that sort of like 37:56 expertise and advice and, and proper guidance. 38:00 So, um, you captured it pretty well. 38:03 So if, um, a family's out there watching this, what's one 38:06 thing that you could say in the next week, 38:09 do this just to kind of 38:11 start the journey. 38:14 I would say since we are talking about ascent, reach out to 38:16 us, 38:17 you know. 38:19 And ask us about, you know, um, 38:22 if you want to start your learning journey 38:24 about private markets, and we have lots of information that 38:27 we can share 38:29 and, and walk you through that. 38:30 But, um, but it's important that you start your process by 38:34 just learning the basics of what is it, 38:36 what is this, this category, what are the different 38:39 uh options within that, and how would you, 38:43 you know, 38:43 start getting exposure to that in, in a thoughtful fashion, 38:47 right? 38:48 So, there is definitely some homework that needs to be done 38:50 before you actually get involved. 38:52 And again, we are here to advise, you know, our clients and 38:55 whoever's interested in doing so, but, 38:58 uh, but, 38:59 you know, you have tools outside, 39:01 outside of that just to do independent work. 39:04 But, but be, be, be very careful, right? 39:07 Of, you know, 39:08 looking at a lot of different data points and then making up 39:11 your mind. 39:12 So just to close it, first of all, thank you for your time. 39:14 It's been a, 39:16 again, I, I'm kind of a geek on this stuff, so I, I love 39:18 talking, talking shop on this stuff. 39:20 It seems to me there are meaningful opportunities in here, 39:23 but they're gonna require 39:25 education, discipline, patience, and a long-term approach. 39:28 And that's what we advise our clients on, and that's what we 39:30 would advise anybody who's interested in this space to, uh, 39:34 To be engaged on, 39:34 absolutely, 39:36 you know, 39:37 here's my final 39:39 point that I'll make is that if, if this is done effectively 39:43 and in the right fashion, 39:45 it can be an extremely beneficial value enhancer within 39:48 portfolios, 39:50 but the caveat is if it's done correctly, 39:52 and there are lots of ways in which it can be done 39:55 incorrectly, so you have to be very careful when getting 39:58 involved, but done correctly. 40:00 You know, it can be extremely beneficial within portfolios. 40:03 I love it. 40:04 Thanks, thanks, Kash. 40:05 Thanks for a meaningful, 40:06 important discussion, and 40:08 thanks to everyone for tuning in and listening to Wealth and 40:10 everything else. 40:10 We hope you've taken away 40:12 something of value for this, and we look forward to our 40:15 next, 40:16 uh, podcast, which will be on impact investing, and we'll, 40:19 we'll be joined by Chad Burlingame who will join us to have 40:22 an exploration on that topic. 40:24 Thanks, everybody.