0:00 Today we're talking about impact investing, how families 0:03 approach it, what it means, and how they're combining impact 0:06 and wanting to have impact with their capital with aligning 0:09 it with their portfolio returns. 0:11 It's a complicated topic. 0:13 It doesn't have one definition, and what we're here today is 0:15 to explore what it means, how it can be used, 0:18 and what are some next steps. 0:20 Joining me today are Chad Burlingame and Kasha Min. 0:22 I will let them talk a little bit about themselves. 0:25 Uh, 0:26 Chad is our co-head of public markets. 0:27 So tell us a little about your 0:29 background. 0:29 Uh, thanks. 0:30 My name is Chad Burlingame. 0:31 I 0:32 began my career with Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds, and 0:35 then I went to a fund of funds, 0:37 uh, where I was selecting managers for long, short 0:40 investing, and now I've been with us since since 2012, and I 0:43 was 0:44 hired to come in and find good investment opportunities for 0:46 our clients. 0:47 Uh, my background is largely in fixed income. 0:49 Income, but we do cover all public markets investing. 0:52 So these are the liquid investments of mutual funds and 0:54 ETFs, 0:55 um, and then also, uh, we have spent a lot of time focused 0:58 on like emerging strategies, 1:01 which we do consider impact investing still to be emerging. 1:03 It's, it's in its teenage years, we like to call it, so. 1:07 Gosh. 1:08 By the way, Chad also leads the impact investing 1:11 efforts for, for US Bank. 1:14 So, 1:14 in terms of my background, um, I, 1:17 you know, was trained as a computer scientist, uh, 1:20 did venture capital at Fidelity Investments in 2000s. 1:25 Went to business school, post that I was doing corp dev, so 1:28 basically buying companies. 1:31 And um 1:33 previous to joining US Bank, uh, I was with a fund of funds, 1:36 private equity fund of funds called Fort Washington. 1:39 And I joined US Bank in 2016 to help set up the private 1:42 markets program. 1:44 So when I go back to just the evolution of our business, 1:47 we had nothing 15 years ago, and now I, I believe us to be 1:51 very close to industry leading in our approach to both 1:54 impact and private capital. 1:55 So, I'm glad you guys are here. 1:57 As we think about impact investing, 1:59 it has a lot of different meanings, and the conversations 2:03 I've had with families in our world is 2:05 they're really moving more towards, I want my capital to 2:08 have some kind of an impact. 2:10 I know it may have some relevance to returns, but I may be 2:13 willing to 2:14 compromise a bit of returns because I really want to see my 2:17 wealth do good as well as have returns. 2:20 So that's kind of the umbrella of what impact investing is 2:23 from, from my perspective, 2:25 as you all think about it. 2:27 Is the professionals implementing this, how do you think 2:29 about impact? 2:30 Well, how can we define it? 2:31 Yeah, I 2:32 think that's spot on. 2:33 Uh, so impact investment is trying to do good with your 2:35 money, 2:36 but frankly, it's a combination not only trying to generate 2:38 a non-financial return, but also generate that financial 2:41 return, and that's an important component of it. 2:44 The intentionality, but also the desire to get a return on 2:47 your investment. 2:48 Uh, that's how it differs largely from, uh, philanthropy. 2:51 Um, I would also say that there's a lot of granularity to 2:54 motivations. 2:55 We see some families who've come in, uh, seeking 2:59 risk, 3:00 uh, 3:01 seeking to dial down their risk. 3:03 in their portfolio 3:04 that may 3:05 be everything from potentially stranded fossil fuel 3:08 investments, for example, wanting to move away from those, 3:11 uh, to more opportunistic and wanting to invest in some of 3:14 the new emerging areas that do get captured and impact 3:17 investing, such as renewable renewable renewable energy, for 3:20 example. 3:22 From an impact perspective, 3:23 again, I, I'd really like to bring in the philanthropy part 3:26 of it because philanthropy is, 3:28 I'm going to give money away to good causes. 3:30 You may never know 3:31 what the impact, not using that word, overly using that 3:34 word, but what the result is of that. 3:35 There's an emotional 3:37 ROI return on that, 3:38 but not necessarily a financial. 3:40 So how do you help families 3:43 Work their way through to say, uh, is it clean water, clean 3:46 air, 3:47 education, you know, food for the hungry. 3:49 How do you help 3:50 our clients come to those realizations? 3:53 Uh, there is a bit of a heart tug, 3:56 and that's OK. 3:56 We want our clients to be 3:58 connected with their portfolios, 4:01 uh, but impact does span a variety of investment strategies. 4:04 Impact is the term, the umbrella term we use 4:07 for these different approaches, and that spans everything 4:09 from the original 4:11 intentions of screening out 4:13 companies that perhaps people didn't want in their 4:15 portfolios, 4:16 exclusion part of it, correct. 4:18 Socially responsible investing is. 4:20 Often 4:21 termed SRI that captures the uh the, the exclusionary 4:25 effort. 4:26 Then there's ESG, which is really trying to lean your 4:29 portfolio towards market leaders 4:31 who have taken a very focused effort on trying to 4:36 build their 4:37 build their companies to also be good stewards, 4:40 um, 4:40 as it relates to ESRG. 4:42 And then finally, there are, um, 4:44 direct impact investing, which is very high. 4:47 In the non-financial benefits that can be generated, 4:50 um, 4:51 and that's really where this is going, and, and that's why 4:53 we use impact as our umbrella term for the, uh, for the 4:57 approach. 4:58 So 4:58 philosophically, or do, or if you've seen one family, you've 5:02 seen one family with regard to these types of investments, 5:04 or how can you put people into a category or families in 5:07 categories? 5:07 How do you think about that? 5:09 Uh, 5:09 everyone approaches this differently. 5:11 If you've seen one family, you still can get. 5:13 Everyone in the room and get a lot of other, uh, get a lot 5:16 of 5:16 great different opinions on, on the topic. 5:19 So, 5:19 uh, we do help a lot of families with the communication 5:22 piece of it. 5:23 I think it's important uh that there are generational 5:26 differences sometimes with the, uh, 5:28 desire to generate a return first on the investment or 5:31 generate more of that non-financial benefit, but, 5:34 uh, it's, it's not consistent. 5:35 We have, uh, embraced families who really want to talk 5:38 through this. 5:39 That's also part of what we're trying to help. 5:40 Help 5:41 deliver. 5:42 But bottom line, this is an emerging space. 5:44 There's increasing opportunities, and I think that the more 5:47 transparency we bring to this, uh, we can showcase what 5:50 impact can do and where there are still some 5:52 areas that it needs to grow. 5:54 You know, from, from my experiences with, with the families 5:56 that we serve, 5:57 it seems like this is almost a bottom-up 6:00 generational type of thing. 6:01 It's, it's uh, the younger generations are saying we want to 6:05 do good with our investing. 6:07 And the folks that are maybe in my cohort are like, no, I 6:10 just want to maximize returns. 6:11 Are, are you seeing that? 6:12 It's 6:12 not consistent, and we do also see some regional differences 6:15 as well. 6:15 I think it's interesting to see the opportunities that exist 6:18 today versus what was fairly limited only 5 or 10 years ago. 6:23 And then, um, 6:24 the ability to show the non-financial benefit, 6:27 uh, deliver some of that 6:29 story to the investor, 6:30 to the clients, I think that's been very powerful, uh, to 6:33 bring additional 6:34 people involved who were maybe initially a little skeptical. 6:37 OK. 6:38 Um, 6:39 what impact has become central topic? 6:41 Is it a peripheral topic? 6:42 Do you think it's moving more to the center? 6:44 How are you seeing it as part of an investment philosophy 6:47 for families? 6:48 Uh, we have seen assets move away from impact recently. 6:52 Over the past few years, we have seen an overall decline in 6:55 the amount of capital deployed in that area. 6:56 Why do you think that is? 6:57 Um, 6:59 I think that some of the initial 7:00 opportunities were maybe more passive or 7:04 maybe, uh, 7:05 colored by 7:06 overpromising areas that they could really invest in and 7:09 drive that financial return. 7:11 However, we have seen, money move into specific areas and 7:15 become more targeted, 7:16 especially as it relates to, 7:18 um, some of the data center and uh sourcing energy from 7:21 renewable sources, for example. 7:23 I, I think people have become 7:25 more educated. 7:26 In the opportunity sets that are bland versus the ones that 7:29 really can drive home um important non-financial 7:32 benefits. 7:33 So early on, 7:35 everything was impacted. 7:35 Therefore nothing was impact, and people put money to work 7:38 in areas that weren't really having 7:39 what they want. 7:40 Is that what you were seeing, Kash? 7:42 Yeah, but 7:42 then, so my focus was, is private markets, right? 7:45 So, you know, Chad and I, we work closely on, on. 7:48 You know, client portfolios and figure out like if they want 7:51 exposure to private markets, how do they enable 7:54 that exposure, uh, specifically as relates to impact. 7:58 Um, you know, what we saw early on 8:01 is a 8:03 lot of 8:04 interest from clients, but at the same time, the market 8:08 opportunity 8:10 seemed to be 8:11 overpromising or, you know, 8:13 tending to be 8:15 oriented more towards like, here's the good that we do and 8:18 we can also deliver market returns. 8:20 But we have seen 8:22 You know, with the opportunities previously, what happened 8:24 was there was overpromise 8:26 in terms of what can be done, um, both from an impact 8:29 standpoint as well as from a market return standpoint. 8:32 And that pendulum has 8:35 sort of swung 8:36 in the direction of, you know, 8:38 investors becoming a bit more, 8:41 um, 8:42 you know, careful about how they, how they deploy those, 8:45 that, those dollars 8:47 and, and making sure that there's real value, uh, both from 8:49 a market return as well as impact standpoint. 8:52 Yeah, because it seems that 8:54 what is a market return for impact? 8:56 There's really, it's layered, and you, 8:58 you're not gonna get an S&P-like return. 9:00 There's gonna be an opportunity cost when we look at ESG, 9:03 right? 9:03 You're excluding some of the S&P 500 for lack of a better 9:07 benchmark. 9:08 So your performance is by definition could be different. 9:10 It could be better. 9:12 It could be worse. 9:13 But there's an opportunity cost to that is that, 9:16 yes, but you could say that about any type of investment 9:18 strategy, and this philosophy is impact, but if you, 9:22 uh, would approach your investment opportunity set and 9:25 remove some of it, 9:27 by definition, you're, you're correct. 9:28 You're gonna be, uh, 9:30 perhaps limiting your opportunity to generate returns, 9:33 uh, but you could also find some other areas that are still 9:36 within scope that could generate. 9:37 Outsize returns. 9:38 So, we're mindful of that. 9:39 I just, I do think that the opportunity set is expanding. 9:43 I don't think it's becoming more restricted. 9:46 I think people are just being much more targeted with their, 9:49 uh, deployment of capital, trying to generate that 9:51 non-financial return 9:53 in addition to, again, trying to get market-like returns. 9:56 OK, so let, let's drill down. 9:58 So somebody has come to 9:59 you all and said, 10:01 you know, we really have figured out, we like X, Y, Z. 10:04 Pick, pick your, pick your impact. 10:06 How do you go from uh philosophy to implementation? 10:10 How do you go, how do you put that into practice? 10:13 Well, that'll vary by family. 10:14 I will say from the starting point, we have had some 10:17 families who are ready to move their portfolios over on day 10:21 one into an impact version. 10:23 More likely though, it's a conversation and it's a 10:26 deployment of capital that takes place over some time. 10:28 So that natural 10:30 slow building into a portfolio is something we can help our 10:33 families with. 10:34 And I do think it's important to recognize we're not just 10:37 looking at rank ordering your value sets and deploying it 10:42 into those slices. 10:43 It's rather 10:44 taking an existing portfolio that is right for the family 10:47 and now implementing in a more impact-oriented way. 10:50 So we have impact investments across 10:52 all of our 10:53 large asset classes that are now impact versions of those. 10:57 And again, we're very Focused on 11:00 a comparable market returns, 11:02 but then also delivering that non-financial 11:05 benefit, but also intentionality too, and I think that 11:08 that's an important piece. 11:09 Uh, this is not a passive, 11:11 uh, endeavor. 11:12 There are passive funds that do this, but this is really 11:15 intention to try to bring in those 11:17 ESG factors uh and connect them to driving the financial 11:21 performance. 11:22 So, 11:23 so on financial 11:25 performance. 11:26 Uh, do you measure it against, is there a ESG 11:29 SRI benchmark? 11:31 Is there a, how do you think about performance measuring? 11:33 Because there's also the intangible of, you know, I'm doing 11:36 well by doing good kind of philosophy. 11:39 Maybe speak to uh treating our investments the same. 11:42 Yeah, we, I mean, for within private markets, we focus on, 11:45 um, you know, traditional benchmarks, so there is no 11:48 specific carve-out for impact investing. 11:51 It's all considered to be, you know, 11:53 across 11:54 any type of investment. 11:56 What is your 11:57 specific benchmark, market benchmark, 11:59 and that's what we are working towards. 12:01 Right? 12:01 So, regardless of whether there's an impact or not, 12:05 we want to achieve those types of market returns. 12:07 So, our goal first and foremost is to make sure that we can 12:11 earn those types of returns. 12:12 And, and in addition to, 12:15 you know, if the client wants that impact component, 12:17 you know, how does that specific strategy help them get 12:20 there? 12:20 So you're not. 12:22 Offering 12:24 clients, we're gonna 12:25 compromise return for impact. 12:27 We're saying it's an end, not an or. 12:29 That's right, 12:31 but that's our 12:31 approach. 12:31 It's not concessionary, right? 12:33 We're gonna bring the same approach to looking into an 12:35 investment opportunity 12:36 regardless of what the, uh, the strategy or philosophy is 12:39 behind it. 12:40 Same type of due diligence, same same expectations for 12:43 returns and risk profile. 12:45 OK, 12:45 yeah, 12:46 right, as we. 12:48 Step back to say we want to align the, the values with the 12:51 strategy. 12:52 We do have a team that does this sort, this sort of work 12:55 with our clients, and 12:56 the first series of podcasts was, you know, the difficult 12:59 discussions about money, and we had Tom Thieves 13:02 and, uh, Justin Flack on, and they discussed aligning values 13:05 and corporate govern, uh, individual family governance and 13:08 whatnot. 13:08 So we do have that work that's in addition 13:11 to what you all do, but from your perspective, aligning 13:14 values and strategy, how do you think about that? 13:18 Um, 13:19 aligning values and strategy. 13:21 So, 13:21 so, I mean, basically, how do you translate? 13:23 Yeah, you're, you're not gonna set their values. 13:25 They have their values. 13:26 We have to tease those out in many times because 13:28 they can be all over the map. 13:29 Then how do you translate that into an investment, uh, 13:33 uh, strategy? 13:34 Yeah, that's 13:34 a good question. 13:36 I do think a misconception is impact investing is sitting 13:39 down and rank ordering your value sets. 13:43 Uh, by definition, that's gonna mean impact does mean 13:45 something different to everyone. 13:47 Uh, but especially when you get a family's wealth and 13:50 multiple generations, 13:52 uh, the matriarch and patriarch, and their grandkids, 13:55 uh, I, I, I do think that it becomes more of a comprehensive 13:59 portfolio. 14:00 And just cause they, just because they've determined they do 14:03 want impact across their portfolio, we don't throw that out 14:06 and start over. 14:07 We take the existing framework, and now we help bring in the 14:10 impact investments into that traditional framework. 14:13 I think there are 14:15 a myriad of approaches that can be more broad in scope, all 14:18 the way down to be very narrow, 14:20 but it is that balance of that non-financial benefit and 14:23 financial return. 14:24 Um. 14:25 This is not philo uh philanthropy. 14:27 Uh, if you were to look at them as a, as, as being 14:31 equally level set, 14:33 uh, but one person in the family put more of an emphasis on 14:36 that financial return, 14:38 uh, versus non-financial return, 14:40 and then you had someone on the other extreme that put all 14:42 of its weight over on that non-financial benefit with very 14:45 little bit of financial return. 14:47 Now you're really bordering up against, 14:49 uh, philanthropy. 14:50 This is a comprehensive effort. 14:52 Impact investing can be very much a part of your overall 14:57 wealth approach, including philanthropy, but in this case, 14:59 we are trying to generate financial returns for a 15:03 well-balanced and appropriately constructed portfolio for 15:06 the long term. 15:07 Is a 15:09 One of the concepts I had a long, long time ago on impact 15:11 was, 15:12 you've got your portfolio, then you carve out an impact 15:13 portion. 15:15 That 15:16 seems to be a train that's left the station a long time ago, 15:18 and you're looking at impact across the entire portfolio. 15:20 Am I 15:21 hearing that? 15:21 Yeah, the 15:22 sidecar or like a tow allocation, you know, 15:24 just a toehold allocation. 15:26 That's no longer the approach. 15:27 Again, these are comprehensive across all asset classes now, 15:30 both in public and in private, and, 15:32 you know, even diversification in the private side, I think 15:35 has come a long way. 15:36 Yeah, it has, and there are more opportunities than there 15:39 used to be before, 15:40 as, as the general. 15:42 You know, zeitgeist of investment managers move more 15:46 towards, you know, incorporating some of these values within 15:48 their 15:49 regular way of investing. 15:51 So, it's not, it, it used to be a fringe, uh, you know, 15:55 industry back in the day, 15:56 but it's becoming much more mainstream with that sort of 15:59 approach. 16:00 So, 16:00 through that, you can get a good set of diversification and 16:04 again, aligning to the values of the client, 16:07 what, what they are seeking. 16:08 And then combining that with what is um available, 16:12 what is an option, 16:14 you know, it's, it's part of an education process that what 16:16 can you really accomplish 16:18 given your value set. 16:20 OK, so as you, 16:21 so again the whole sidecar idea that that was a thing, so I 16:23 wasn't totally off on that. 16:24 OK, make sure that we got that, 16:26 um, 16:28 what in what I'm hearing you say is we're not compromising 16:31 returns for 16:32 impact. 16:34 But is there 16:35 a trade-off there, or should we just think about it as this 16:37 is just like value investing, there's just, it's just 16:40 another way to invest? 16:41 You know, the performance history is still limited to say 16:45 with conviction, 16:47 uh, if impact investing outperforms the markets. 16:49 Uh, 16:50 I do think we're getting a lot more data and more 16:53 importantly, we're able to analyze. 16:55 It much 16:56 better than ever before, 16:57 uh, but it's still very early innings. 16:59 I said, it's the teenage years for, 17:01 for impact investing. 17:02 It's come a long way. 17:03 There's still a lot more to do, 17:04 um, in terms of standardizing reporting, 17:08 uh, in terms of really highlighting the non-financial 17:11 benefits that are being pulled out of, 17:13 uh, the financial returns. 17:14 So really making that connection. 17:16 Um, but overall, again, I, I think this is something that 17:19 has come a long way, 17:20 um. 17:21 It spans everything from 17:23 socially responsible investment or SRI, that exclusionary 17:26 piece, and that could be more focused on, uh, you know, we 17:29 helped the family 17:30 with, um, 17:31 um, an interest in taking their religious doctrine and 17:36 applying it to their portfolio, screening out some 17:38 industries such as, 17:39 um, alcohol and firearms, for example. 17:42 That's gonna have one type of return objective. 17:45 Uh, we've seen ESG, which is again leaning towards industry 17:48 leaders. 17:48 We had a fund manager who 17:50 Uh, visited a large, uh, consumer products company, visited 17:54 their R&D department, spent a lot of time there, 17:57 highlighted that, yes, you have great 17:59 Options going in many different directions, but this, this 18:02 soap endeavor to take, uh, the liquid out of it and make it 18:06 into a dry powder, and ship everything to then the consumer 18:10 adding the water at the very end, 18:12 uh, could save in terms of energy efficiency. 18:15 Uh, that was very powerful for the R&D department to hear 18:18 just how much opportunity there is. 18:20 That's, that's real engagement. 18:22 In, in trying to drive change in a publicly traded company, 18:25 that's a different type of investment profile. 18:28 And then lastly, the high impact, um, 18:30 you know, making direct loans to underserved communities and 18:34 affordable housing such as builders and lenders, etc. 18:37 Um, that may be a little bit more 18:38 lending rate type of, of, uh, market return versus, um, 18:43 um, you know, high total return from, from an equity 18:46 evaluation standpoint, so. 18:48 So, 18:49 from an investment, and this is actually almost an 18:51 intangible perspective, 18:53 how do you measure 18:54 impact? 18:55 How do you measure the good that is done to the investment? 19:00 And it may be a tough, it may be an impossible question to 19:02 answer. 19:02 I'm just, no, it's not 19:03 impossible. 19:04 Uh, we would just like to see, we'd like to see 19:07 more improvement there. 19:08 That's where the industry is really at this inflection 19:10 point. 19:10 Uh, I get excited from the 19:12 data analytics piece, able to dissect again some of that, 19:16 uh, driver performance. 19:18 Uh, a pivotal moment came in 2015 when the UN 19:23 decided on, uh, or built some, some, um, 19:26 coalescence around 19:27 these, uh, sustainable development goals. 19:29 These were not geared towards finance, but the finance 19:32 industry has taken it and ran with it. 19:34 Uh, it, it, 19:35 they are using these SDGs as the pillars for measuring that 19:39 non-financial benefit. 19:41 Still tough to quantify the magnitude, but again, we are now 19:45 measuring the direction of it even better as far as what 19:49 endeavors they're seeking to, 19:51 to align with. 19:52 So that could be uh clean energy, that could be uh water uh 19:56 use reduction, um, 19:58 it, it's, it's a very good roadmap, 20:02 but now we have increasing amounts of data and then data 20:05 analyzing ability. 20:06 I think it's gonna get better and better. 20:08 Are you finding the same thing? 20:10 Yeah, it's similar and, and, you know, in some cases, you 20:12 can really directly measure the tangible benefits. 20:15 Like, for example, if you're investing in sustainable 20:17 energy, right? 20:18 Or, 20:19 you know, uh 20:20 clean water or, you know, just water conservation. 20:24 I mean, if, if the company is focused in that direction, for 20:26 example, if you 20:28 are investing in a geothermal 20:30 energy producer, 20:32 right, that is meant to, you know, directly reduce your 20:36 carbon footprint. 20:37 Now, 20:38 that, that is very tangible, right? 20:40 Like, cause you're producing energy from 20:42 natural sources. 20:44 So, 20:45 being able to find those nuggets, 20:47 as Chad pointed out, it's not a perfect set of benchmarks or 20:51 data, 20:52 but you can actually make those connections directly by the 20:55 investments that you make. 20:56 And because the, to me, and I, I'm involved with the 20:59 education philanthropy back home, 21:01 and we can measure outcomes. 21:03 You can see test scores, you can see graduation rates, you 21:06 can see there's, there's measurable things. 21:09 In a lot of these investments, I assume the companies are 21:11 big. 21:11 This is a part of a company. 21:12 It's an important part of a company. 21:14 But it's just super hard to get tangible feedback. 21:17 So, but I'm encouraged to hear that's evolving. 21:21 Similarly, 21:22 we can now measure upskills training as it relates to 21:26 providing education to 21:28 people at different levels of employment and tracking them 21:31 much longer and seeing the net benefits or maybe where 21:34 things are not working as well with that upskills training. 21:36 So, 21:37 That's a good example again, where it's improving. 21:39 We're not, uh, we're not there yet, but it's, it's getting 21:42 better and better, and 21:44 seeing a picture over a long period of time can certainly 21:46 help for 21:47 deploying capital in the future about, uh, to, to the 21:50 solutions that work best. 21:51 Yeah, 21:51 I assume we don't do it this way, but also if a company is 21:54 approaching something in the right way. 21:56 We may not be able to measure the outcomes, but we believe 21:59 that the process is gonna yield good results, and that's, 22:03 in some cases, that's just gotta be good enough. 22:05 There 22:05 are some approaches to ESG which deploy capital to industry 22:09 leaders, 22:10 uh, in ESG endeavors, and then there are other approaches 22:14 who are deploying capital to the companies that may not be 22:18 starting at the top, but are 22:20 Um, showing the best amount of improvement or a real effort 22:24 to improve. 22:24 So, 22:25 again, it all fits with that broad endeavor 22:28 in this area. 22:29 Um, Impact is the umbrella term we use. 22:32 We think there's a lot of opportunity. 22:33 There's no single way to do this, but we are trying to help 22:36 our clients understand again where this works and where this 22:39 still has some room for improvement. 22:41 Yeah, this would seem in the private markets, this seems 22:44 like it would be ripe for 22:46 a lot of ESG, a lot of, a lot of work in that area. 22:50 Um, 22:51 but it also feels very venturous to me. 22:54 It is, is that, 22:55 yeah, fair. 22:56 It is definitely, 22:57 there is that 22:58 venture component because some of this is unproven and 23:03 you are aligning values to, you know, trying to narrow down 23:06 your scope in terms of where you want to invest. 23:09 And, you know, as you narrow down the scope, you know, 23:12 there is the potential of actually missing out on good 23:15 opportunities 23:16 while you are focusing on that specific category that you 23:19 want to target, right? 23:21 For example, if, if you want to increase the number of 23:24 women-led businesses, right? 23:27 And your focus is that, OK, I want to sponsor new 23:31 founders who are women. 23:33 Um, 23:34 then, you know, your, your focus tends to be in that 23:36 direction. 23:37 So, now, you are self-selecting, 23:39 you know, again, you know, those founders. 23:41 But 23:42 the question is then that, you know, are you capturing the 23:45 full market set of opportunities? 23:47 So, you have to be careful of how do you go about that. 23:50 And then similarly on the 23:52 sustainable energy side, things have evolved to a point 23:54 where it's much more economically feasible. 23:57 Um, you know, 10 years ago, 24:00 the sustainable energy sources were not as economically 24:03 feasible as traditional, 24:05 but that market has changed quite a bit. 24:07 So now it becomes much more 24:09 market return-oriented versus just pure impact. 24:12 So, it all depends on what 24:15 you focus on, what specifically. 24:17 It can be venture or it can be something which might be much 24:21 more 24:22 market, if you will. 24:23 Are there um 24:24 private entities that are just focused on? 24:27 Stuff that we're looking at for funds or is are they just 24:30 basically too small and too nichey for what we're trying to 24:32 accomplish? 24:33 Yeah, I mean there are opportunities. 24:36 There are firms that are focused squarely on stuff like 24:38 this. 24:38 Um, 24:39 there are, that's 24:40 a technical term, 24:41 stuff like this. 24:42 Yeah, well, 24:43 impact-oriented opportunities, right? 24:45 And, um, you know, there are firms that just squarely focus 24:49 on, you know, finding those opportunities and sourcing and 24:52 vetting them. 24:53 And um 24:55 there are funds that actually just want to do that, you 24:58 know, 24:59 impact component. 24:59 But 25:00 as we talked about earlier, 25:03 there was a big push in that direction, maybe 5 years ago, 25:06 but that trend has subsided a bit. 25:09 And 25:10 because, you know, back then there was just a groundswell of 25:12 like impact investing was, you know, gaining a lot of 25:15 traction and momentum, 25:17 which has slowed down a bit, but 25:19 rightfully so because, you know, it was part of the exercise 25:22 of discovering like what is 25:24 good versus what is, 25:26 you know, stretching a bit, right? 25:28 So, we've come to a point where there's more of a 25:31 stasis, if you will, of, OK, this is the opportunity set and 25:34 we can grow from here. 25:36 Yeah, I was, uh, a friend of mine was talking about an 25:38 investment in Great Bend, Kansas. 25:40 You guys know where Great Bend is? 25:41 Nobody, nobody really does. 25:43 And it was, that's where apparently they park all the used 25:45 tires, and they're gonna take these used tires and turn them 25:47 into 25:49 oil or gold or something, 25:50 and it was gonna be get rid of all these used tires. 25:52 So it sounded great, you know, it didn't really pan out too 25:55 well. 25:55 So I have a hunch there's a lot of 25:57 things like that out there, probably well-intentioned, but 25:59 not necessarily exactly, 26:01 yeah, you have people who have that intention. 26:03 They want to actually enable those. 26:05 Uh, categories and opportunities, but then again, 26:08 is there a real economic value of doing that, right? 26:11 So, 26:12 you know, the industry went through that discovery process, 26:15 but I think we are at a point now where, 26:17 uh, you know, we've discovered those potholes and, and sort 26:20 of like re-emerging from that. 26:21 And finding the right opportunities. 26:24 Go 26:24 our, yeah, our message on this is that ESG investing or 26:28 incorporating these factors, 26:30 uh, really is just 26:32 trying to drive better 26:34 investment 26:35 decision making. 26:36 So 26:37 whereas 26:37 by the companies or by the individuals, by the 26:39 individuals, um, I do think that. 26:43 It used to be viewed as a separate endeavor, 26:46 but it's consistently becoming more and more right on top of 26:49 traditional investing, and that's how we view it. 26:51 That's a good thing, right? 26:52 That's, that's an evolution, it's not a different endeavor, 26:55 it's right on top of, uh, in compliments. 26:58 Uh, traditional investing. 26:59 You're just trying to improve your investment decision 27:02 making, and if you're pulling in 27:03 more and more 27:05 risk factors and also potential return, 27:07 uh, opportunities with these factors, 27:10 uh, that's moving the ball forward. 27:11 So, I, I, I don't. 27:13 Uh, 27:14 you know, we've seen maybe some pullback in number of fund 27:17 managers offering dedicated impact offerings. 27:20 Um, 27:21 however, increasingly, we are seeing traditional investment 27:24 managers more and more incorporate these ESG factors into 27:27 their investment decision making. 27:29 So it's, uh, just from a greater good perspective, 27:32 the more capital that flows into companies that are doing 27:35 More good. 27:36 I think I'm, uh, that's grammatically incorrect, but go with 27:39 me. 27:39 So more capital goes in companies doing more good that 27:41 elevates their share price and should then encourage more 27:45 people to do the right thing. 27:46 Is that, 27:47 is there a macro kind of, 27:49 it's a little esoteric, but 27:51 Uh, there are, I think, you know, one of the things we look 27:53 at is the cost of capital. 27:55 There seems to be rewarding companies who are 27:57 taking the endeavor here, kind of the same, 28:00 exactly, yeah. 28:01 So I, I think from a, um, efficient use of capital, 28:04 uh, the more committed you are to doing the right thing with 28:06 your capital, there does seem to be a reflection in the 28:09 marketplace, 28:10 uh, being rewarded for that. 28:12 Yeah, I've, I've obviously been a little out of touch with 28:14 this market as things have evolved. 28:15 As you look over the next 5 to 10 years, 28:19 where are we going? 28:21 You don't want you wanna take 28:22 that first. 28:23 You go first. 28:24 Well, from then 28:25 full private that was a punt 28:26 if I ever saw. 28:28 Well, for private markets, you know, as we spoke about, as 28:31 Chad mentioned, like this is 28:33 evolving from, you know, sort of like, uh, 28:37 impact investing as a separate category to like blending in 28:40 with the traditional markets in general, 28:42 and, and, 28:44 you know, we've seen that 28:45 osmosis, if you will, from just being a sidecar to actually 28:49 being part of the general, you know, 28:51 broader marketplace. 28:53 So we see opportunities where 28:55 Even more of a traditional investment manager will actually 28:59 talk about like what impact or, 29:01 you know, how have they added value within, in, in that, on 29:05 that front. 29:06 So, I, I, I see, I expect that trend to continue 29:09 where everyone, 29:11 regardless of whether they are doing pure impact or not, 29:14 having some sort of metric within their 29:16 framework that here's how we are adding societal value, you 29:20 know, or impact value, if you will. 29:23 I think the reporting is gonna get better and better, and 29:26 that'll pull more people in. 29:28 Secondly, I think that data analytics will help make that 29:31 connection specifically between 29:33 uh the non-financial benefits that you're going after 29:35 actually driving that financial return. 29:38 Um, and then overall, I just think this is as cash is 29:41 describing. 29:43 No longer looking at risks and trying to take things out of 29:45 your portfolio. 29:46 I think there's real opportunities here that now people are 29:48 really trying to go after. 29:49 So, 29:50 uh, I mentioned the 29:52 data centers and the explosion in growth there. 29:55 Well, increasingly important is the, uh, data center, 29:59 uh, providing its own energy source and not tapping into the 30:02 local grid. 30:03 And as renewable energy has become part of that, I mean, 30:06 that's right in the wheelhouse of impact investing. 30:08 So, 30:09 um, I think there's a lot of opportunity where this is 30:11 going. 30:11 Um, 30:12 but the more transparent and also the more focused on 30:15 opportunities, not just risk mitigation, I think, 30:17 I think it'll continue to expand. 30:19 It's interesting to talk about the data centers. 30:21 I was, we're in San Francisco filming this 30:23 as I came in from Denver, flew over Nevada. 30:26 There's the biggest solar array, I think, in the world, just 30:28 north of Las Vegas. 30:29 Yeah, I've seen that. 30:30 It was the coolest thing, 30:31 and it was like it's got a, 30:33 I don't know what it said, because the way they refract the 30:35 sun into the center, they can provide. 30:37 Energy 10 hours after the sun goes down because it just it 30:40 stores it that efficiently and then sends it out so there's 30:42 a lot of technology 30:44 evolving in that. 30:45 So 30:46 thank you all for a great discussion. 30:48 As, as I listen to what you guys are saying, it sounds like 30:52 the market's evolving. 30:53 It's evolving away from sidecars or the, the terminology of 30:56 the day to 30:57 integrate that into your overall 30:59 investment philosophy. 31:00 But first you gotta figure out what you care about. 31:03 And that, that's something that 31:05 families can do on their own. 31:07 Uh, 31:07 we're not trained 31:09 in that area, but we can certainly help families to 31:11 kind of focus at least on what they want to do. 31:14 The investment 31:15 horizon is actually the investment portfolio of 31:18 opportunities is expanding because more and more companies 31:20 are taking this seriously. 31:22 The and, not the or, invest with impact and get market-like 31:26 returns. 31:26 That is, I think, a, a big evolution of this. 31:29 Um, if there's one thing that our families could do in the 31:32 next 31:33 week, if they're thinking about this, 31:35 what would you, what would you offer up? 31:38 I mean, 31:38 education is, and we talked about this in the last episode, 31:41 you know, educating on what this is all about is, is 31:44 helpful, but is there something else they might be able to 31:46 do? 31:46 I'd say have a conversation with a family member about 31:48 impact investing. 31:49 Our, our families are having those conversations, so parents 31:52 with grandparents and, 31:54 and grandparents with grandkids, 31:56 um, have the conversation. 31:57 I think it's, it's very valuable to get some perspectives, 32:00 different perspectives on 32:02 wealth and investing from members of your own family. 32:05 And then, um, we're a resource here for impacting investing 32:08 when people are ready to take a, a deeper look at 32:09 it. 32:10 Awesome. 32:11 Yeah, thanks, gentlemen. 32:12 Great discussion and thank you for joining us on the Wealth 32:15 and Everything Else podcast. 32:16 We look forward to our next discussion. 32:18 We'll wrap this series up with Phil Scherer, who we started 32:21 episode one with, 32:22 to really talk of this, bring this all together for you at 32:25 your family level and how you should be thinking about 32:27 investing through the lens of legacy. 32:29 Thanks for joining.