John and Phil_1_Video.txt English (US) 00:00:00.280 — 00:05:54.010 Welcome back to Ascent Wealth and everything else. Today, we focus a new series on investing through the lens of legacy conversations about ultra high net worth families, how they prioritize balancing risk, balancing return with multi-generational families, and the competing interests that big families have, whether it be liquidity, timing, next generation wealth, risk tolerance, the things which are important for families, both as a start today and is a is a move through time. We're coming to you today from Cincinnati, our cybersecurity headquarters, so you'll see some fun stuff flashing up behind us on various topics. And as a is the largest, one of the largest banks in the country, we take cybersecurity very seriously. And we thought this would be a good place to to bring our next conversation to you. So I'd like to welcome Phil Scherer to us. He is a managing director of investments for ascent, and he spends a lot of time with families working through their options and how they should approach investing for the long term will welcome. Great. Thanks, John. Here. Um, you have a super interesting background. Tell us a little bit about yourself. And, you know, you strapped on the, the helmet for, for a great number. So, so so tell us a bit about your background. Yeah. So my story in a nutshell, I consider myself and probably forever will consider myself a recovering floor trader. So I started my entry into the business, so to speak, about 25 years ago in the early 2000, kind of right after the the tech collapsed on the floor of the Chicago Board of Options Exchange was a market maker or trader. So if you were to have come into the pit and in order to the pit in the early 2000, back when Microsoft was about $30 a share, believe it or not, there was about 25% chance that I and my firm were on the other side of that order. So that was a very kind of quantitative existence, a very short term oriented, very kind of high speed environment that I was engaged in. Then I had a kind of a mid-career pivot to the institutional space, endowments and foundations. I was an adviser to many national endowments and foundations, which was a kind of seismically different type of opportunity, much slower, much slower, much more thoughtful. I would just say football players really came to mind. You know, in trading you were committing capital and making decisions in minutes. In the INF space. It was decades. Endowments, foundations. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. A little acronym there. It's all good. Um, it was a much more methodical, much more thoughtful type of investment environment. You were evaluating things like private equity, venture capital and hedge strategies that they fit. Uh, the nice benefit there, of course, is that they were tax exempt because they defied Ben Franklin for certainties in life. Another layer of complexity for the ultra high net worth families. Yeah. So, you know, in a nutshell, I think both of those experiences have prepped me very well for my my job at ascent. The trading aspect made me understand really the microstructure of markets very well and the E and F experience has really trained my mind to kind of focus more long term and be more thoughtful and strategic and allocating. But you also had a fast paced former life in college, didn't you? Uh, kind of. I'm, uh, also recovering, physically recovering, uh, collegiate athlete. Yeah. I played football at Harvard for a number of years back in the late 90s. That's really very awesome. Do the two the pits actually still exist? I think the Trading Places frozen concentrated orange juice pit doesn't even exist anymore. You know, it's been 20 years since I've been up there at this point. Um, they do for the larger indices, as I understand. Um, when I was there, you know, early 2000, the pit was winning at that point, a lot of it was going kind of off floor off exchange at that point. Uh, but the lessons from the pit exist even without the pit. Uh, yeah. I just I just remember those scenes of traders flashing signs and trying to. I never could figure out how they knew what was here. Everybody had their own kind of colorful jacket which identify which firm you were with. And you're an acronym to designate your your status. Val was I think, Valentine for Trading Places. So so let's move into the alternate word families. So as you think through how families are approaching investments or portfolio construction, what are the key things from a high level that you think about and help our families think about when they engage with us on an on an investment type mandate? Yeah, sure. Yeah. I think the easy answer, in terms of kind of what makes multi-generational families different and kind of unique, is that similar to the INF world, the Endowment Foundation world, there's a kind of a time horizon extension. You're not maximizing a portfolio for kind of one person's life. It's expected to exist decades, if not many decades into the future, if not perpetual in some cases. Uh, and so in that regard, what we can invest in as an investment manager, as a PM is much more unconstrained. So we're able to commit to things like private equity. Venture capital funds and strategies with ten to 15 to 20 year life to them. And that can still be suitable and appropriate for those types of portfolios. You're also able to kind of take more concentrated bets within portfolios. I think one of the nice features of the multi generational kind of space is that liquidity oftentimes is not a major issue. There's ample liquidity. So you're never in a situation where a volatile market comes to be. And you have to kind of sell into a down market. The clients can generally kind of stick with their strategy and ride it out, which I think is generally the right decision and generally affords them the ability to kind of concentrate risk and, um, kind of swing for the fences more from a return perspective. You know, bigger picture, I would say. What makes the space different is that, um, 00:05:55.770 — 00:09:10.070 it's kind of the The multi-generational family expands and the complexity expands, it expands exponentially. So if you think about a traditional wealth engagement, you know, a single retiree has one set of needs, one portfolio. It's very unidimensional. As you get to the multi-generational space, you can have the matriarch and the patriarch, three adult children, grandchildren you could have trust for a great grandchildren. They haven't even been born yet. Charitable interest, that all kind of pull from the same bit of capital and that can become very complex very quickly. So I think the key task from an investment perspective is how do you kind of manage that and refresh it over time? Because we think in terms of I mean, I'm a CFA, so as an investor, buy low, sell high. Sure. You know, balanced risk in return. But now we're balancing wealth preservation with liquidity needs, with multifamily opinions of things that should be going on and priorities and goals that they have and yet to be more in great grandchildren. So it becomes a a really complex. Yeah. It can't be. It's a Rubik's cube So you got to figure out. So how do you. As you talk with these families. Defining purpose is important. How do you help them through those sorts of of dynamics is to think about what is it that they need to be thinking about. But, you know, from a goals perspective, I believe firmly that their goal should be upstream from the portfolio and not the other way around. I think too often in our space, when you say upstream from the portfolio, define that a little bit. For me, the conversation should begin with the family's goals, and then we should understand what the goals are, what the constraints are, what the parameters are, and then build the portfolio to support that kind of not the other way around. So if you've seen one ultra high net worth portfolio, you've seen one ultra high net worth portfolio. So the worst thing in our space would be a model portfolio of a 7030 model portfolio. Trying to take that and kind of jam it in every client situation. That's not going to work out well in the multi-generational space, simply because the needs are just too complex and too different. So when you as we step back and engage with families, there's multiple generations. How do you think about aligning across multiple generations? You know, I like to say that the investment part of my job is the easy part putting dollars in the ground. It's the really challenging part. And the more kind of awful part is working with the various family members various generations, G1, G2, G3 and trying to understand kind of what their competing priorities are because they're always going to be a little bit different depending on their stage in life and kind of their needs in the capital, and in getting them in a room on a conference call to really hash out kind of what those tradeoffs are and how we can eventually come to a consensus and, and build a portfolio that works for all. Yeah, we have, um, when we work with families, investments is part of what we do. We also have a family office services group that engages with families to work on communication and trust and. Intergenerational wealth and rising gen education. So all that plays into. What you do and work collaboratively with them to to help build this. 00:09:11.230 — 00:11:28.999 Background for lack of a better word, a foundation for what they want to do. What they want to do with their wealth. So now we've had those conversations. Sure. And we have a three generation family that's got rising Genz in their teens and the patriarch matriarch and the the middle generation. How do you think about constructing a portfolio for that? What is it you engage with and how do you help them think that through? The short answer is that it depends. Um, you've seen one family office. You've seen one family office. I think that's a very good statement. Um, it really depends on kind of who you're talking with. Um, we have developed this concept and utilize this concept of an income portfolio, a lifestyle portfolio, a growth portfolio, a legacy portfolio. Uh. Oftentimes that's how the the generation won or kind of the wealth creator generation thinks and it's pleasant. So and we've done this for a lot of clients is a liquidity portfolio is what they need to exist today. Their cash flow is exactly that. Then you have a lifestyle portfolio which manages their maintain their lifestyle regardless of what happens elsewhere. Then you have more of a risk seeking. And I don't mean that in a we're just going to go shoot for the moon, but you have that. There's less constraints on that portfolio with regard to liquidity needs and risk. Is that what you're describing? Exactly. So the lifestyle portfolio would generally be invested in less equity sensitive type investments. And so what that means is it's not going to oscillate with the market as much. It's going to have kind of a lower beta as we say. And the thing there is that the income from that portfolio, if it's primarily fixed income Investments of all types could be private credit. It could be a public credit, it could be reinsurance, for example, things with low equity market sensitivity, but you can reasonably count on to provide a yield to support lifestyle. Having that in place is kind of the ballast in your allocation ensures that for the growth portfolio, where you are seeking risk and return that if you do get into a down market, you don't have to kind of dip into that corpus and sell it. The worst time it provides got a certainty. Overall, what I like about that approach is 00:11:30.240 — 00:28:41.160 families can feel good that they had their transactional needs taken care of, that their lifestyle is not going to change because you see the beta, the volatility of the market. Many of our clients just it's they just they want nominal positive returns. They don't necessarily need to match the market. And then that frees them up to relax and take a long term horizon view of that investment portfolio. Sure. So when you look at that investment portfolio. We in the next couple of episodes, we're going to talk about private capital and impact, which are less liquid, you know, longer term options. But how do you think about that construction then, as you actually dig, dig in with these families in terms of the makeup of kind of what that what is it? What is the liquidity portfolio look like? What's the lifestyle portfolio look like, and what is the investment portfolio look like in just general terms? Yeah, sure. So this is kind of the fun part of my job is the actual construction, the easy part of what you said earlier. Exactly. So in general, pretty simplistically kind of put it this way, we will utilize public markets for liquidity, for optionality. You can actually change your mind when you have an investment in the public market. So if you're invested in a stock or a bond or a liquid investment in general, we can pivot if we need to to change the allocation. You can also in that portfolio, better harvest. Yes, exactly. For tax purposes it's in the liquidity portfolio on the investment portfolio, particularly if it's long term it's there's less tax harvesting. Yeah. Tax control is a major a major part of what we do as an organization. You know, a client might have a business interest and operating business that is very profitable one year. There's a massive gain on that side of the balance sheet, the income statement. And we need to look to the investment portfolio to offset some of those gains. With the loss within the liquid investment portfolio, you can actually do that. You can identify the security that's held at a loss. You know, in a broadly diversified portfolio, there will always be at least one holding that's that's trading at a loss. You can sell it, reposition the capital in a like asset and still kind of maintain the same kind of portfolio property. So that's kind of the role of the liquid assets in the portfolio. If you think about the illiquid assets, the private capital, the venture capital, the hedge strategies, those are in the portfolio. More for return enhancement. We believe firmly that there is an illiquidity premium in markets. Define what that means. So if you think about your options as an investor, you can invest in a liquid strategy that trains on an exchange. You can buy and sell and kind of get out daily, or you can invest in like a private equity fund where you might be committing capital for ten plus years. That capital can buy assets that are unavailable in the public markets. An operating company, for example, that's going through a generational change and needs liquidity. The private equity company could come in and kind of buy that exposure out, uh, which is a great deal if you're able to kind of lock that capital up for ten plus years because there's no certainty you can kind of get out exactly when you want. Uh, so in so that's kind of the theory behind the illiquidity premium. You're giving up liquidity to, to access and enhance return. That ideally should be above and beyond what you can get in the private market. I think historically, the numbers would show that there's obviously years where the market, the private markets have outperformed public parking, public markets. You know, there's been good vintages, there's been poor vintages. But on average We tend to believe that that's going to exist in the future. And we're going to we're going to drill down on that in episode two. I think what's important is that the the, the sourcing, the diligence, the structure, the pricing of those deals is something we have expertise that within us Bank is an extremely good track record of performance, that we bring value to clients through that. Exactly. Yeah. We a dedicated team that is constantly scouring the globe, uh, has a number of relationships with top tier managers that were able to get access to and really add value for our clients in that regard. I think it's a it's a real advantage to our clients to have access to that. Yeah. So when you put it all together, I mean, this is again, you've seen one, you've seen one, but is are there percentages you do in, in lifestyle, in, uh, liquidity, lifestyle and investment portfolios? How would you how does that how do you get to those percentages. Because that's where the rubber meets the road. And then security selection to meet that obviously. Sure. So that's a highly customizable, Um, exercise. There's not one right percentage, just generally speaking. So 6040. Equities fixed is no longer the thing. Yeah. Model portfolios do not work. And and our client portfolios I mean you could envision a a client that has a just massive balance sheet and limited spending needs. Well in that case, the liquidity portfolio, the lifestyle portfolio might be much smaller. They might need only 10% of their net worth in the lifestyle portfolio, and the other 90% can reach for growth, can reach for legacy type structures, versus a person that has, you know, a 10th of that might need over half their their overall portfolio in the lifestyle piece. Just given that their, their spending needs are, uh, pro rata more significant. So how do you then. So now we start with the big picture is what are your family's goals and what do you want to do with that? Then we come down to here's how we think about the three buckets we've articulated. Then we think about security selection. Sure. How do you how do you go about that? Uh, so, you know, broadly speaking, Diversification is our friend. I believe firmly that diversification is the one free launch in finance. Um, I think that was, uh, some famous economist. Milton Friedman would just go with Milton Friedman. Sure. Glad to have. So you want to be diversified? Concentration is rarely ever your friend. Um, there's times where we want to increase risk within the portfolio. You know, coming out of a 2008, for example, uh, when when fear was rampant, you might want to increase risk, but you still want to do it in a diversified way. Um, you want to make sure that your asset classes are balanced. You want to understand factor exposure. So getting equities last year. So you have this portfolio of seemingly different asset classes. You might have a traditional uni bucket a fixed income bucket a high yield bucket high yield bond bucket, an equity bucket a emerging market equity bucket. There's all these different slots you can kind of fill in. Oftentimes many of those different slots will have kind of overlapping exposures. So in the case of high yield for example. So high yield bond is a is a bond with an above market yield. But that carries a higher risk associated with it. So it's kind of part fixed income. And it behaves partly like equity. So you don't want to have a massive high yield exposure thinking that you're allocated just a fixed income. You want to understand that there's some equity factor exposure within that to make sure that you're kind of titling the overall allocation to your to your liking. So yeah, I mean, when I was running money, you mean you'd have a bunch of stocks that seem very disparate? Sure. That they all have interest rate exposure and whatever kind of exposure. So it's that's great to look at is we work with clients that have heavily concentrated positions, say an executive that retires. So how do you work with that sort of a situation? Yes. That's obviously a common example of many of us sense clients. You know, they come into us After a career as a CEO of a public company, for example, and there might have 70 to 80% of their net worth in that one stock. Typically, it's a methodical plan that we have to put in place over a many a year period. The tax budget associated with it. There's also kind of more esoteric vehicles we can use exchange funds and and stuff like that. More immediately get out of the exposure. But it's really a conversation with that individual to understand the sensitivity around taxes, the desire to diversify and kind of what that time plan will look like. And because I think we also have a lot of clients that have heavy real estate exposure or energy exposure. So we are looking to offset that's not the right word, but to work within what they have their existing creative portfolio around that. And we actually do a completion portfolio. Sure. And what does explain what that means. Because that's. Yeah. So that we can help a client with. Yeah. So a completion portfolio would be you know understanding kind of the more Significant exposure. It could be a real estate business. It could be an operating company. Understanding kind of what that business is engaged in, kind of what are the macro factors that impact the core economic exposure within a client's portfolio, and then making sure that the portfolio we build side by side with that kind of dovetails and complements that core exposure. So, you know, we have a large client that I work with personally that's a real estate developer. And, you know, 95% plus of his net worth is in the real estate, commercial real estate developing business. So first and foremost, he wants zero real estate in our portfolio. Then he wants to make sure that the, you know, cause real estate markets can get volatile from time to time. Yeah. Capital needs can become significant. He wants to make sure that we have ample liquidity within our investment portfolio, that that could support the core business, should the market necessitate that other things like lines of credit on the core portfolio or instrumental And an engagement like that, making sure that there's ample liquidity, that we can tab quickly with limited tax consequence to kind of support the core operating business it makes makes total sense. Yeah. It's again, you've seen one family. You've seen one family. So is we pivot to kind of governance and decision making. How is that. How do you assist families with governance decision making and just actually execution. Sure. So you know, creating alignment when there's multi generations in play is the kind of the art of the game. Um, you might have a G2, G3 kind of all with the C at the table, all with modestly different and kind of competing priorities. I think it's open communication, it's dialog, it's committing periodically. It's every two years to updating and discussing the investment policy statement. I think it's a great practice. It's a nice formal exercise to to create a forum that every two years, at least, we're going to have the opportunity to kind of voice our concerns and to document it kind of way at those types of meetings. I believe firmly in recording minutes and passing those minutes out to the parties that be, uh, to just create a memorialized, uh, framework for, for them to kind of remember and understand the discussions that happened. But, you know, by and large, discussion of communication, plain language, I think, generally can drive consensus and get us to a point where we can all agree on kind of the optimal path forward for a kind of a shared pool of assets. Yeah. And this in this world, in a ultrahigh net worth world, there's just a lot of people at the table. Yeah. And a lot of I won't say competing interests, but in some cases they are. Yeah, sure. So having that governance, that document that that alignment because I won't say agreement agreement is probably too streamlined. Yeah. But acknowledgment acknowledgment is is really important because wealth has a tendency over time to become fragmented. And so what you're doing is helping this these families be successful through the generations. And that governance and the leadership there is really important. So that's a good call is and we we touched on this a little bit. But as we go through time families needs change. We go from generation 1 to 2 to 3 to 4. And in some cases we have we work with families that have 6 or 7 generations. How do you think about adapting? I know that comes back to revisiting the IPS government policy statement, but how how do you work with families to adapt over time, and how do you bring in the disparate voices to to get alignment? Yeah, sure. Um, what we don't want to happen. We want to make sure that the family's goals drive the portfolio and not kind of the market gyrations driving the portfolio. I think oftentimes there's a desire, you know, after a volatile period like the early part of 2020 or 2008, 2009, uh, that can spook investors and that type of market environment can make families think that they need to change, which sometimes you should change things on margin in response to a market like that. But in general, I'm of the mind or of the mind that the goals of the family should be driving the change and not the market driving the change. So it's creating that forum of, you know, every, every two years at least if there's major family developments, maybe developments with the operating business that is the core of the family's wealth. Um, at those junctures in time, making sure that there's a formal meeting to to flush things out again, we call it discovery or rediscovering, you know, at the beginning of every relationship, we want to engage in a thorough discovery session with the family, which is effectively a Q&A to make sure that we understand all the varying, uh, variables and constraints and idiosyncrasies that the family might have, but then commit to doing that on a on a periodic basis. Can I ask those probing questions to make sure that the portfolio reflects the kind of the current wisdom and current state of the family. Yeah, it's a it's actually a lot of the fun of what we do is to really dig in with these, these families. So as I step back and just kind of tie this all together, the way I look at it and near the expert, but I will throw it out there and you can refute if I'm not on track is in investing for ultra high net worth families, actually for everybody, but specifically with the complexities of the families that we deal with. It's not an event. It's a process. Sure. And it starts with discovery, which is a is a great word. What is a family? What do they stand for? What do they want to stand for? What is their liquidity needs? What are their time horizons? What are their competing interests? What does the next gen look like? What's their philanthropic endeavors, which we'll talk about in another episode. So that's first. Then second is how do we build a portfolio constructed portfolio around that. Then third is how do we populate that with securities. Then fourth is monitoring and make sure that it stays in line with with the with the the goals of the family. So is that did I capture what you're saying? You hit that in the head. Well that was kind of my goal. The term that comes to my mind is stewardship. I love that, I think in multi-generational families, that word and that concept is much more relevant than in traditional kind of wealth management. Yeah. The word stewardship is a very powerful word because it's it's the family's wealth to use, but it's also to preserve the legacy of the family, to pass on to the next generation and make sure that they understand. So one, just a quick aside. When you look at next gens or rising gens is actually Prince Charles was a rising guy. He was seven years old. But if you look at rising gens, um, in their teens, do we think about those and how do we bring those folks into the. Yeah, oftentimes many families will start including kind of that age, uh, family member in the meetings. Initially, it's more of an educational kind of bring them up to speed on the nomenclature and the language. And there's there's different kind of best practices on how and kind of when to do that. But I think generally late teens is a pretty good time to, uh, begin to get indoctrinated in kind of the language and the, the discussion. And I assume that's when they become more financially aware and more curious. Sure. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And more interested because, I mean, it's going to be theirs at some point. So they need to kind of think about that. So if you were to advise a family on one concrete thing that they could potentially do in the next week, which is make it time bound as well, what would you advise? Um, I would say, and this is hard for me to say. So I was an economic major in college and I focused on more microeconomics. Trading is a very microeconomic activity, is micro as it gets. So as hard as that is to say, I think you should focus on the macro instead of the micro. Don't focus on the minutia of the market. Focus on the strategic kind of family elements that should be represented in the portfolio, you know, and one thing I always tell clients is that if you can't tell me in one sense what your portfolio is supposed to do, what's its purpose, not what's invested in what's its purpose. There's probably more discussion that we should have, because at the end of the day, every family member should to kind of understand what that is. So you almost need, in business parlance, an elevator. Yeah, exactly. A moment on your portfolio. So. Got it. Okay. Okay. Phil, thank you so much. Thanks for a great conversation. We we believe very strongly in helping families be successful helps the world because it makes the world a better place with what they can do. So thank you for your insights. Thank you. And thank you for joining us. We are going to pivot in the next couple of episodes to working on private capital. What is private capital, how does it fit into a portfolio and alternatives as well as impact? So please join us for episodes two and three and investing through the lens of legacy. Thanks for joining. 00:28:46.320 — 00:28:46.400 Us.